Re: [HumJanenge] Need advise section 8-1(i)

Dear Mr Gupta

Thanks...my RTI was not regarding papers put in front of cabinet.. most of queries were , what happened on suggestion required by PMO, had Mr Sibal/Mr Mukherjee submitted their coments. The amendment is getting delayed because of non action at their end

further i have asked what all were amendment proposed.. i guess Ministry is under obligation to put up such amendment on theur website under section 4. They should have called for public comments as well.. so in totality there is secrcy in the matter

please advise 

regards

Mohit 

---

From: M.K. Gupta <mkgupta100@yahoo.co.in>
To: humjanenge@googlegroups.com
Sent: Tue, 22 March, 2011 3:45:59 PM
Subject: Re: [HumJanenge] Need advise section 8-1(i)

Recently, there was a case in which PIO denied information on the almost same analogy citing the decision of disclosure about the papers being put up before the Cabinet for consideration and approval.  CIC rejected this stating that that case is not similar to the information / proposal contained for the consideration of the Cabinet and rejected the plea of the PIO. This was probably reported in the media within 15-30 days.

---

From: Mohit Goel <mr_mohitg@yahoo.com>
To: humjanenge@googlegroups.com
Sent: Tue, 22 March, 2011 2:48:57 PM
Subject: Re: [HumJanenge] Need advise section 8-1(i)

Dear sandeepji

thanks for below ...article has given some useful insights to prepare for appeal in front of FAA

regards

Mohit 

---

From: sandeep kumar <drsandgupta@gmail.com>
To: humjanenge@googlegroups.com
Sent: Tue, 22 March, 2011 11:03:06 AM
Subject: Re: [HumJanenge] Need advise section 8-1(i)

Please follow the link below and see if it is helpful in any manner.
http://www.frontline.in/fl2721/stories/20101022272108200.htm


On 3/22/11, Mohit Goel <mr_mohitg@yahoo.com> wrote:
> Dear Members
>
> Need advise on below matter
>
> Last year Ministry of Consumer affair, Food and Public distribution proposed
> amendment to Consumer Protection act. Proposed amendment were placed before
> Union Cabinet during July 10 meetings. Media highlighted proposed amendments
> that ministry had plan to do in the act.
>
> During the meeting Honble PM felt need of some fine tunning and amendments
> were referred to Shri Pranab Mukherjee and Shri Kapil Sibbal for comments
> etc.
>
> It is being 6 months and there seems to be no progress on matter.
>
> I filled RTI last month asking for progress made on matter, when matter was
> received by above ministers and when did they commented on amendments , when
> Mr
> Sibal/Mr Mukherjee completed the procedure and sent back amendments ,file
> noting
> etc.
>
> I received reply from PIO of above said ministry stating  matter is Secret
> till
> the time amendment are notified by Department and information cant be
> furnished
> at this stage under RTI act 8-1(i)
>
> Need advise of learned members if PIO is correct in withholding information.
> Please advise any case law/CIC decisions where information was allowed under
> section 8-1(i).
>
> Regards
> Mohit
>
>


--
Dr. Sandeep Kumar Gupta
989, Sector 15-A, Opposite bishnoi Colony, Hisar-125001, INDIA
Phone: 91-99929-31181