Saturday, August 6, 2011

[HumJanenge] Monitoring the existence & functioning of "RTI Cells"

In May 2011 DoPT advised other Ministries / Depts to set up RTI Cells.

http://circulars.nic.in/WriteReadData/CircularPortal/D2/D02rti/1_12_2010-IR19052011.pdf
(Please read the annexures carefully - which if actually implemented would sort out a lot of the "process" problems)

What is the feedback from our members / have you experienced any improvements ?

Sarbajit.

[HumJanenge] FILE RTI, GET ABUSED,

FILE RTI, GET ABUSED,

M K Gupta

 

          Shri Brijesh Kumar of Dwarka, Delhi filed an RTI application to Municipal Corporation of Delhi and he was stunned to read the on-line reply by the Supdt. Engineer (DEMS)/III that he (Brijesh) is Ch*ti* (an abuse in Hindi). Stunned to know about this reply, Shri Anoop Rohera, Jt. Secy. Dwarka Forum lodged complaints to Shri Shailesh Gandhi, IC, Central Information Commissioner and Ms. Rajni Abbi, Mayor, Delhi. and Now, Shri R.C. Patnaik, CMO, MCD has informed to Shri Gandhi that the illegal act has been done by a mischievous and unknown person who appears to have got the access to the system through the use of default password.  Shri Gandhi, IC has directed the CMO to identify that person till 1.00 p.m. on Tuesday.

Friday, August 5, 2011

[HumJanenge] Re: Full Penalty imposed on CPIO, National Library, Kolkata

So the necessary implication of this kind of reasoning is that the
CIC must decide the 2nd appeal within 10 days of receipt or else the
concerned IC is equally liable for penalty upon himself.

For those interested in the maths (neglecting postal time periods)

DAY 0 = Day CPIO is meant to supply information (but doesn't)
DAY 30 = Day up to which FIRST APPEAL can be filed upto
DAY 60 = DAY for FIRST APPEAL decision
DAY 90 = DAY up to which 2ND APPEAL can be filed.
DAY 100 = DAY to decide 2nd Appeal.

NB: Day 100 = max. day for penalty (Rs.250 x 100 days = Rs. 25,000)

On Aug 5, 1:57 pm, Manoj Pai <manoj...@yahoo.com> wrote:
> The complainant had filed two complains against the staff of the library and later followed it up with an RTI Application. This was not responded to and he approached the commission. What is interesting in this decision is that "The RTI application has been filed on 12/07/2010. Hence the information should have been provided to the Complainant before 12/08/2010. Instead the information was provided to the Complainant only after the order of the Commission i.e. on 12/07/2011." Further the decision has an interesting line "The Respondents appear to have confused the purport of the RTI Act and included 'grievance redressal' within the ambit of the same and therefore no information was provided initially."
>
> Check full decision at the following link
>
> http://www.rti.india.gov.in/cic_decisions/CIC_SM_C_2011_000133_SG_132...
>
> Manoj

Re: [HumJanenge] POSTING NOTICE

Sir,
 
That is long overdue.

--- On Fri, 8/5/11, Sarbajit Roy <sroy.mb@gmail.com> wrote:

From: Sarbajit Roy <sroy.mb@gmail.com>
Subject: [HumJanenge] POSTING NOTICE
To: "humjanenge" <humjanenge@googlegroups.com>
Date: Friday, August 5, 2011, 11:25 AM

Dear Members

In view of the high proportion of OFF-TOPIC (unrelated to RTI) emails being mindlessly forwarded to this group, and the requirement of moderators being forced to read such emails to evaluate if they are suitable for circulation, the moderators have identified that there is a small number of abusers of our group's facilities, and decided that members who mindlessly post OFF-TOPIC emails to this group's email ID, SHALL HENCEFORTH BE UNSUBSCRIBED IMMEDIATELY

[HumJanenge] Full Penalty imposed on CPIO, National Library, Kolkata

The complainant had filed two complains against the staff of the library and later followed it up with an RTI Application. This was not responded to and he approached the commission. What is interesting in this decision is that "The RTI application has been filed on 12/07/2010. Hence the information should have been provided to the Complainant before 12/08/2010. Instead the information was provided to the Complainant only after the order of the Commission i.e. on 12/07/2011." Further the decision has an interesting line "The Respondents appear to have confused the purport of the RTI Act and included 'grievance redressal' within the ambit of the same and therefore no information was provided initially."

Check full decision at the following link

http://www.rti.india.gov.in/cic_decisions/CIC_SM_C_2011_000133_SG_13243Penalty_T_64121.pdf

Manoj

Thursday, August 4, 2011

Re: [HumJanenge] POSTING NOTICE

Dear Mr. Sarbajit Roy,

I got subscribed to this group without being soliciting. Still i found this group is very useful to communicate with likeminded people of our country.I would like to know if you mean RTI only RTI act and related activities only or really a forum to get right to information.If u and moderators think earlier one I think you are toning down the spirit of free information which forms the basis of Right to Information Act. Except communal , abuse and slang why you want to stop other to exress their views. It is like meri lathi to meri sunna hoga type dadagiri in name of moderating. Plz avoid this.

Its true that some times offtopic mails comes but just delete it.

rgds


On Fri, 05 Aug 2011 11:25:57 +0530 wrote
>Dear Members

In view of the high proportion of OFF-TOPIC (unrelated to RTI) emails being mindlessly forwarded to this group, and the requirement of moderators being forced to read such emails to evaluate if they are suitable for circulation, the moderators have identified that there is a small number of abusers of our group's facilities, and decided that members who mindlessly post OFF-TOPIC emails to this group's email ID, SHALL HENCEFORTH BE UNSUBSCRIBED IMMEDIATELY



Treat yourself at a restaurant, spa, resort and much more with Rediff Deal ho jaye!

[HumJanenge] POSTING NOTICE

Dear Members

In view of the high proportion of OFF-TOPIC (unrelated to RTI) emails being mindlessly forwarded to this group, and the requirement of moderators being forced to read such emails to evaluate if they are suitable for circulation, the moderators have identified that there is a small number of abusers of our group's facilities, and decided that members who mindlessly post OFF-TOPIC emails to this group's email ID, SHALL HENCEFORTH BE UNSUBSCRIBED IMMEDIATELY

Re: [HumJanenge] FAX TO RM ON DOB Word Document.doc

Where are we going ? National interests because DOB of the present COAS was ;leaked, only Grahm Greene  would be able to conjure a connection !!
 
Sangh has been judgemental on the calibre of the previous two Chiefs as also on the ones to come. What inside facts do they have  ? I think we are suffering from too much time at hand & joining issues as a great intellect-exercise. Babus are laughing with chpota peg on the Golf Course.. i think that bit from the Vice President of the Sangh was well below the belt but it onl;y exposed his own problems.
 
We need to putb a stop to this inanity  now & here. let us not give ammo for the ever eager media to do us down. In the larger interset , it is the ARMY IMAGE which is at stake. I do'nt think we are helping the cause.

with warm regards,
 
 
Lt Gen ( retd ) D P Singh


--- On Thu, 4/8/11, Aridaman Jit Singh <aridaman@nishanjustice.org> wrote:

From: Aridaman Jit Singh <aridaman@nishanjustice.org>
Subject: Re: [HumJanenge] FAX TO RM ON DOB Word Document.doc
To: humjanenge@googlegroups.com
Cc: "Ranjit Rai" <ranjitrai123@gmail.com>, "Brig YUDHVIR" <s.yudhvir@gmail.com>, "parvez" <parvez1942@yahoo.com>, "Vinod SAIGHAL" <vsaighal@bol.net.in>, "Veterans for justice" <MilitaryVeteransForJustice@yahoogroups.com>, "militray banglaore" <MilitaryVeteransBangalore@yahoogroups.com>, "Bombay Sappers" <veteranbombaysappers@gmail.com>, "109" <chardikalan_chandrakala@googlegroups.com>, "manmohan" <mohan26@hotmail.com>, "Amit Bhaduri" <amitarjun@blueyonder.co.uk>, "rajendra" <RSingh305@aol.com>, "manmohan" <nrisoldierleague@gmail.com>, "Indian Veterans Group" <indianveterans-subscribe@yahoogroups.com>, editor@rajputindia.com, editor@tehelka.com, "AVM S L Dutta (Retd)" <sldutta@hotmail.com>, "Ms Barkha Dutt" <barkha@ndtv.com>, "B.B.Desai" <bbdesai@gnfc.in>, "kiran bedi" <kiranbedi2005@yahoo.co.in>, "ajai singh" <ajaysingh.ald@gmail.com>, "surendra srivastava" <surendra@loksatta.org.in>, "Govinda Menon" <tcgmenon@hotmail.com>, "Dr Trivedi" <atcptrivedi@gmail.com>, "afroz sahil" <afroz.alam.sahil@gmail.com>, nagdads@yahoo.com, "B P S Chandel" <bps1chandel@gmail.com>, "Baldev Lall" <brlall@gmail.com>, "PRO" <proarmy@rediffmail.com>, "Col B Singh" <rajeshwari76@gmail.com>, "Sat" <satpalaul@airtelmail.in>, "Brig Kr KN Singh" <sherrysapper@yahoo.com>, "Wing Cdr Gautam Guha" <shona.guha9@gmail.com>, "Maj Gen SP Aul" <satpalaul@airtelbroadband.in>, "Maj Gen SP Aul" <sat.aul@gmail.com>, "Brig HS Chaudhary" <brigharcharansingh@rediffmail.com>, "Col B Singh" <rajeshwari67@gmail.com>, "bhawani" <deepbhawani@hotmail.com>, "P Renjen" <genrenjen@yahoo.co.in>, "SPS Rawat" <rawatbik@yahoo.com>, "Viajay Oberai" <oberoivijay@hotmail.com>, "Maj Gen Rajinder Singh,VSM" <raj2jas@gmail.com>, "Maj Gen Lakhwinder Singh,YSM" <lakhwinder4@hotmail.com>, "Lt Gen NS Malik, PVSM" <gen_malik@airtelbroadband.in>, "Col M S Krishnamoorty" <colmoorthy@airtelmail.in>, "kmehra" <kmehra@ndf.vsnl.net.in>, "Jeet Khanna" <genjk@satyam.net.in>, "JEET KHANNA" <genjk@sify.com>, "Kamal Khanna" <kml.khnn@gmail.com>, "kamal khanna" <kkkhanna46@yahoo.com>, "Maj Gen JS Kapoor" <kapoorjs@rediffmail.com>, "Lt Gen V K Kapoor" <vijayrit@hotmail.com>, "Atul Dev" <atuldev@airtelmail.in>, "def Air Mshl (retd) s r deshpande" <srdeshpande@argusindia.com>, "Rear Admiral Kuruvilla ?" <georgekuruvilla2000@gmail.com>, "Maj Gen Pushpendra Singh ?" <genpushpendra@gmail.com>, "Brig P T Gangadharan ?" <brigadierptgangadharan@gmail.com>
Date: Thursday, 4 August, 2011, 10:24 AM

Dear Cmdre,
                     congratulations for going beyond the schedules of chotta pegs and golfcourse. It is inspiring to see channelisation of positive energy to India's transition to democracy from a colony and it will take ages to transform the colonial mindsets.The perception of "intrusions" or "crosspostings"  emanates from colonial hangovers or else it should not be seen as infringement of personal property rights.Benjamin disraeli had said "Colonies do not cease to be colonies because they are independent".
As long as things are debated in the larger interest of the society and the state,everyone should be welcome.
Democracy and its attendant institutions are not the sole prerogative of state functionaries and elected representatives or some google group moderators but each and every citizen of India is the focal point of this democracy.citizen is the focal point of a constitutional democracy governed by rule of law, the citizen or the ex-serviceman for that reason is not mere subject of state in democracy but holder of rights and bearer of obligations and jointly responsible for the smooth running of the state and society. Democracy is not delievered by state institutions and its functionaries but by the citizens, who mandated constitutional democracy and have every right to question and express to the people in position of power, mandated by him to discharge the official functions.The FAX in question has raised very pertinent issue on the functioning and role of people in it.
It is inspiring development that people from uniforms services have began to become part of the journey dedicated to transition of this colony to a true democracy.
'threat of deleting the email addresses is attendant to the highest intellectual complexes emanating from "I am there" mentality and not a healthy sign for groups dedicated to democratization. Any way, every one has contributed something and deserves healthy thanks.
Aridaman Jit Singh
On Wed, Aug 3, 2011 at 7:49 PM, Sainiksangh <gs@sainiksangh.org> wrote:

Sainiksangh has no inclination for getting into arguments on a reflexive response to a matter which otherwise would seize concern of any with slightest sense of military self esteem let alone national pride. Admittedly golf courses are poor nurseries for cultivating such values, indeed just the opposite. Lessons on how to conduct and what is self esteem for veterans therefore coming from those in glass houses with apparent penchant for knee jerk outburst, itself intriguing, can have little intellectual honesty.  Such lessons must be drawn from rank and file not club wielding self styled 'patriarchs'. Unsurprisingly the Commodore skips and evades the central message in our FAX apparently loves his bookkeeping tastes by recourse to references to bureaucratic functioning. We are not an office but a citizen's setup conscious of our obligations, the issues in FAX being beyond the perfunctory. Its mismanagement as made public by the government itself, raising more distrust than faith in it, can only be warranting   a strong rejoinder unless we are a lame duck and sick nation which is we are not hopefully. Let it be clear that the government is fully accountable to the people and not to Crown of England any more or be it White House today! The Commodore's critique is therefore a self inflicting averment, an insidious distraction from culpability of a serious nature of which author makes no mention. Instead missing the wood for trees through unsure   and motivated judgment interpreting the FAX as brief for the Army Chief as an individual when it is not. But decidedly for overriding need to cleanse the mess at higher ranks a mission at his hand which as far as possible must not see change of horses midstream through a controversy of this nature by design. Commodore's silence on this tantamount to condoning and defending wrong is a reflection of flippant inconsistency in his sermons , incompatible with military straightforwardness. He seems carry the tone of an official spokesman for the 'other' camp whatever this may mean!                 

 

Sainiksangh is not an archaic set up with colonial mindset which the author seems to exhibit richly in his rejoinder ( not his fault we  groom functionaries in our still colonial styled military establishments trying to brush up English NOT grooming leaders as why should white masters should have  to groom brown  leaders anyway  , but this continues to this day vigorously  as we carry the nostalgia of Raj and its admirers  ). Our next paper to the RM is exactly for  nationalizing our training philosophy at foundation level and bring quality in intake else we  remain saddled with vagaries of character carried by sub calibre material in a profession where only honour and awe must prevail; admittedly Hindu bourgeoisie never had a military culture to assimilate such values as history bears out amply ; why history is not taught.  The founding principles of Sainiksangh therefore encompass nation building engagement, defining a citizen role for the veteran where he is remains an extension of the military institution outside the establishment when  he chooses to identify so loyally and not peddle agenda for others. This makes us non stereotype engaging in many fields. This is 50th interface with the establishment on various issues exerting pressure to move policy, admission of education subsidy for war widow's children being one.

We are not used to intrusion in our territory by any with coercive intent and share our views only to evoke thought with positive interaction and not to invite subversion. We also do not need any recognition or accolades which we entertain only from children below 18. At our functions the local DM sits in invitees pavilion while watching village girls and boys being the VIPs.

We hope this settles the avoidable and wasteful engagement of this nature.

chauhan
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
- Original Message -----
From: Ranjit Rai
Cc: Brig YUDHVIR ; parvez ; Vinod SAIGHAL ; Veterans for justice ; militray banglaore ; Bombay Sappers ; 109 ; manmohan ; Amit Bhaduri ; rajendra ; manmohan ; Indian Veterans Group ; editor@rajputindia.com ; editor@tehelka.com ; AVM S L Dutta (Retd) ; Ms Barkha Dutt ; B.B.Desai ; kiran bedi ; ajai singh ; surendra srivastava ; Govinda Menon ; Dr Trivedi ; afroz sahil ; nagdads@yahoo.com ; B P S Chandel ; Baldev Lall ; PRO ; Col B Singh ; Sat ; Brig Kr KN Singh ; Wing Cdr Gautam Guha ; Maj Gen SP Aul ; Maj Gen SP Aul ; Brig HS Chaudhary ; Col B Singh ; bhawani ; P Renjen ; SPS Rawat ; Viajay Oberai ; Maj Gen Rajinder Singh,VSM ; Maj Gen Lakhwinder Singh,YSM ; Lt Gen NS Malik, PVSM ; Col M S Krishnamoorty ; kmehra ; Jeet Khanna ; JEET KHANNA ; Kamal Khanna ; kamal khanna ; Maj Gen JS Kapoor ; Lt Gen V K Kapoor ; Atul Dev ; def Air Mshl (retd) s r deshpande ; Rear Admiral Kuruvilla ? ; Maj Gen Pushpendra Singh ? ; Brig P T Gangadharan ?
Sent: Wednesday, August 03, 2011 12:11 AM
Subject: Re: [HumJanenge] FAX TO RM ON DOB Word Document.doc

This Fax was an unnecessary interference by Saniksangh as this a matter  between the AG and MOD and the Chief and what the Chief accepts in the highest and finest traditions of the fine Indian Army he joined and lived with a date in the ARMY LIST, all his illustrious career.

The Army Chief has to set an example and  ensure the controversy ends with the Governments decision, right or wrong. A fax by a self grown organisation  is in poor taste but its a democracy so they can do so,  but to imply  the next Chief if he comes in in 2012 will not be as good as Gen VK Singh smacks of a personal bias and interest in the case though the Fax  cleverly say they have no personal bias. Typical of India seen by PM's statement in 2G/CWG  issued by PMO not himself. Do generals want to be such.


Are we readers of this group so gullible ?  .........If Gen VK gets a lease of life till 2013 a Dynasty Change will take place in the senior line up of the Indian Army and that in an Armed Force will show that we are in 2G category too, intellectually corrupt. We retired, should keep clear and so in many cases, unless you join journalism when more people at large will judge . We retired are  setting up groups that  are not recognized by the Armed Forces and are capable of embarrassing them, like the return of medals. The President does not care for that as RM should dis regard this fax in the WPL.

I hear Sanik Sangh is doing great work in villages and that is laudable .....Let those in uniform now do their job.....We old timers did ours. We would not have liked outside interference.

Lets be retired soldiers, sailors and airmen of self respect.


Cmde Retd Ranjit B Rai as discussed at the golf course today.

On 2 August 2011 06:26, Sainiksangh <gs@sainiksangh.org> wrote:

            vf[ky Hkkjrh; iwoZ lSfud la?k

        All India Ex Soldier's League

 

 
        In Service of the Nation, Society and Fraternity                                                                  

          web site sainiksangh.org Telefax 011-26891513

    e-mail : gs@sainiksangh.org ; web sainiksangh.org

    Tele:     011-26891513   

   HQ : 6090-B8 Vasant Kunj New Delhi                     Priority – URGENT            

To:

Shri AK  Anthony

H'ble Raksha Mantri

 

FAX 

From: Lt Gen GS Growl, PVSM  (rtd)  President  AIESL

Maj Gen APS Chauhan (rtd) President Sainik sangh Vice President AIESL

 

 

 

 

Fax 23015403

 

Pages: 4

 

Copy to Defence Secretary

 

Date:  Wednesday, July 27, 2011

 

Security: Unclassified

 

Transmitted by   Maj Gen APS Chauhan

  

 

 

 

Firstly: Greetings from our fraternity and integrated Graam Samitees.

Secondly:  This memorandum is a fall out from the regrettable controversy  on  COAS's date of birth attracting a public debate  causing  great concern at  the grass root level. 

Thirdly: You are conscious of the assault on reputation and virtues of the military institution on a continuous basis which must have a telling effect not only on our national prestige but pointedly on those sections of rural which field our fighting elements. Now it is the controversy about the date of birth of the incumbent Chief of the Army Staff Gen VK Singh.

On the face if it and simplistically an error or anomalous entry but irreconcilable and incorrigible being on his record. The ramifications of this are however grave and which cannot be wished away or disposed of as simplistically as may appear. This faux pas introduces extremely undesirable and damaging conflict of interests and a predicament for the establishment as to which date should decide the date of retirement of the General. Any choice will be tantamount to becoming arbitrary and challengeable.

Fourthly: We take this opportunity to share our position on this is a matter of concern for the entire veterans community as tarnishing of military image must hurt it most. There are a few postulates which stand out and give direction to resolving this extraordinary and exceptional case.

A: That the anomaly exists and was allowed to, over the entire period of the General's service speaks poorly of our  efficiency in  house keeping,  responsibility for which rests entirely with the Ministry.

B: That the anomaly has been made public, when this is part of a highly confidential document and taken with its timing ,  raises alarm on vulnerability, the lack of integrity and reliability of  those handling these sensitive documents. It follows that this lapse has remained covered in books even if by neglect but leaked with full knowledge of the repercussions of this thus a deliberate act of felony.  This requires immediate action to fix responsibility and book the culprits.

C: Per say and axiomatically the clerical error thus assumes a diluted status becoming inconsequential when taken in context of the larger implication and gravity of the act of leaking the information. This must become a primary concern at the Ministry as it manifests a threat within, in these troubled times and more ahead, with which there aught to be no delay in dealing.

D: Security ramifications aside, a controversy of this nature involving the head of a military service of the nation should never have come to be debated as a law problem in public making us a laughing stock. Military management is not playing snakes and ladders as much as battles not won in court room's .This points acutely at our insensitivity to nuances beyond the immediate for the impact this can have at national level. Specifically sending wrong message to the soldier that the system that fields his commanders is highly suspect, which we think it is , denting his  pride and trust which can result in breakdown of discipline, which is showing so and for which only the  Ministry is finally accountable to the people.

E: Gen VK Singh took charge at an unenviable moment when our military image was already   getting a battering at hands of sub-calibre generalship which logically led him to pledge publicly to attend to the health of the institution as his top priority. As any duty conscious incumbent would in the troubled circumstances and restore confidence at large. That despite a protracted neglect of the institution no earlier incumbent found it necessary to engage such, was in itself extraordinary and a relief.  Indications are that is being apparently pursued vigorously as evident from the indictment of two previous Chiefs for involvement in land scandals.  Indeed his predecessor had not only brought along a dim reputation from Northern Command of which you are fully seized, raising another public controversy, but understandably did all to cover misdemeanors of other  senior officers under his charge some to our knowledge  later indicted or waiting to be  for similar misconduct. The fact that despite his reputation Gen Deepak Kapoor had  been clearing successive rungs of advancement was itself bewildering and intriguing which we are sure is receiving your fullest attention as there cannot be a greater urgency at the Ministry than to shore up its invulnerability, both the MS Branch and the JS (G)  not always carrying the distinction of upholding the credibility of their own offices. Officers with 5 point reports have made to Army Commanders. The leaking of information thus has an uncanny but definite connection with the previous Chief during whose tenure this leak was presumably detected. This affair therefore smacks of a deep conspiracy which must be exposed with urgency in national interest.

F: The higher interest of the Army and national security must remain the overriding factor to set the case at rest without further speculations and delay. An unsettled state of this nature is bad for military morale, distracting and impeding the COAS to conduct his business and disrupting continuity where this may be vital and critical in implementing measures to clean up the inherited mess which is deep and extensive.  For this his services must be available for the maximum period possible much this may mean against vested interests wanting to extract their pound of flesh from this anomaly. We must instill confidence in the military and set a route for  much needed corrections and reforms in officer grooming without which the military cannot be fitted out to deliver the  consequences of which can be mind boggling; provided ofcourse there is a will and inclination to correct the decay.

G: The clerical anomaly must therefore not fog the exercise of decision making in the best interest of the country. Both military and civil bureaucracy must not disconnect with the psychology of the soldier, understood so well by the colonial masters nearly brought to their knees once, which understands only one language that his Chief cannot be brought under dispute whatever the nature as he must be spotless in every way  to lead them into battle. We have been avoiding this test so far. 

H:  RM's advice to the military not to fonder media is sound but must be addressed to his Ministry too to create conditions to obviate the need for this.

Fifthly: This memorandum is not a brief for any individual or  a lobby for any interests but one against such what is  inimical to the interests of the soldier and the nation.  An alert on setting right the standards of functioning and conduct which has a bearing on lives of men.

 

Signed

 

chauhan




--
Cmde (R)Ranjit B Rai
Vice President Indian Maritime Foundation Tel 24330087 M 9810066172
International Correspondent India Strategic. Broadcaster
C 377/443 Defence Colony New Delhi 110024
www.indiadefenceupdate.com



--
Aridaman Jit Singh
For Team Nishan
http://www.nishanjustice.org/
http://community.webshots.com/user/Nishan_Justice
http://call100.blogspot.com/

"Highest office in a democracy is not that of the President or Prime Minister but Patriotic Citizen"-Team Nishan
-----------------------
NISHAN Campaigning HQs.
Plot No.571(1st Floor), Sector-2,Urban Estate, Kurukshetra-136131(Haryana),India. Tel. - +91 1744 232013,TeleFax- +91 1744 232570,(M) +91 9466283343
--------------------------------
NISHAN Liaison office Haryana: S.C.O.86(Top Floor), Sector-17, Kurukshetra-136118,(M) + 91 9466283343
-------------------------------------
NISHAN Registered Office Delhi: 9-CSC, DDA Market, A-Block, Saraswati Vihar, Delhi-110034,India,(M) + 91 9899007392

Re: [HumJanenge] FAX TO RM ON DOB Word Document.doc

Dear Mr Jit Singh & other members

This group is India' premier mailing for RTI (Right to Information) issues. It is not just another soapbox for venting grievances on corruption and misgovernance, and neither is
this mailing list a democracy or run as a democracy. There is also a limit to the number of emails per month (300) we allow to be sent from this group.

The emphasis here is on generating UNIQUE CONTENT of interest to the majority of our members along with the occasional forwards on burning issues of the day.

The question of "crossposting" has been previously debated and voted on by members who overwhelmingly (3:1) decided that crossposting was intrusive and a nuisance which should be prohibited.

Sarbajit
List Moderator

PS: for your ready reference I am appending below the group regulations

*GROUP REGULATIONS*
Please read the following group regulations carefully, these regulations are enforced strictly and without discrimination for the benefit of our membership

*1) MESSAGE POSTS*

   - *a)* Message posts to be directly relevant to RTI / Right to
   Information. The focus is on RTI in general and not on specific instances
   affecting an individual member. The prime focus is on discussion of gray
   areas of the RTI Act 2005.
   - * b)* No abusive language to be used in message posts
   - *c)* No "Cross-Posting" (multiple copies of the same message from / to
   other egroups)
   - *d)* All posts in English language only (or with accurate translation)
   - *e)* No communal, sexist, racial, casteist etc message posts
   - *f)* Fostering  brotherly feeling among RTI activists all over India
   and organizing concerted action through message posts.
   - *g)* Posting of "news" reports on RTI by simply copy-pasting is banned.
   This is also a copyright violation issue which we (and googlegroups) take
   seriously. If a news report is important, post your views / concerns with
   the LINK to the article.
   - *h)* Posts to be kept short and focussed. Long scholarly arguments are
   strongly discouraged.
   - *i)* Posts in reply to be trimmed (by deleting the previous post so
   that only relevant portions which are at issue to be retained).
   - *j)* Self publicity or publicity for NGOs (and their programs) is
   strictly prohibited.
   - *k)* Address message posts to the group (and not to individual members)

   - *l)* SPAM (spammers, and spam harvesters) is not tolerated.

*2) FREQUENCY OF POSTING *

   - *a)* This group shall strive to limit itself to 300 messages per month.
   The list owner is empowered to take all steps necessary to achieve this.
   - *b)* Of these 150 message are reserved to the list owner and about 10
   "guru" members who shall be invited to assist the list owner. The list of
   "guru" members shall be widely publicised and updated from time to time
   - *c)* Other members are allowed to post upto 3 messages per day (24
   hours approx) and 10 messages per month.
   - *d)* Members are requested to limit / control the frequency of their
   posts to this list and avoid personality based squabbles on this group.
   - *e)* Please try to combine reply posts, and avoid the temptation of
   replying to posts immediately.

*PMK*
List Owner


On Thu, Aug 4, 2011 at 10:24 AM, Aridaman Jit Singh <aridaman@nishanjustice.org> wrote:
Dear Cmdre,
                     congratulations for going beyond the schedules of chotta pegs and golfcourse. It is inspiring to see channelisation of positive energy to India's transition to democracy from a colony and it will take ages to transform the colonial mindsets.The perception of "intrusions" or "crosspostings"  emanates from colonial hangovers or else it should not be seen as infringement of personal property rights.Benjamin disraeli had said "Colonies do not cease to be colonies because they are independent".
As long as things are debated in the larger interest of the society and the state,everyone should be welcome.
Democracy and its attendant institutions are not the sole prerogative of state functionaries and elected representatives or some google group moderators but each and every citizen of India is the focal point of this democracy.citizen is the focal point of a constitutional democracy governed by rule of law, the citizen or the ex-serviceman for that reason is not mere subject of state in democracy but holder of rights and bearer of obligations and jointly responsible for the smooth running of the state and society. Democracy is not delievered by state institutions and its functionaries but by the citizens, who mandated constitutional democracy and have every right to question and express to the people in position of power, mandated by him to discharge the official functions.The FAX in question has raised very pertinent issue on the functioning and role of people in it.
It is inspiring development that people from uniforms services have began to become part of the journey dedicated to transition of this colony to a true democracy.
'threat of deleting the email addresses is attendant to the highest intellectual complexes emanating from "I am there" mentality and not a healthy sign for groups dedicated to democratization. Any way, every one has contributed something and deserves healthy thanks.
Aridaman Jit Singh
On Wed, Aug 3, 2011 at 7:49 PM, Sainiksangh <gs@sainiksangh.org> wrote:

Sainiksangh has no inclination for getting into arguments on a reflexive response to a matter which otherwise would seize concern of any with slightest sense of military self esteem let alone national pride. Admittedly golf courses are poor nurseries for cultivating such values, indeed just the opposite. Lessons on how to conduct and what is self esteem for veterans therefore coming from those in glass houses with apparent penchant for knee jerk outburst, itself intriguing, can have little intellectual honesty.  Such lessons must be drawn from rank and file not club wielding self styled 'patriarchs'. Unsurprisingly the Commodore skips and evades the central message in our FAX apparently loves his bookkeeping tastes by recourse to references to bureaucratic functioning. We are not an office but a citizen's setup conscious of our obligations, the issues in FAX being beyond the perfunctory. Its mismanagement as made public by the government itself, raising more distrust than faith in it, can only be warranting   a strong rejoinder unless we are a lame duck and sick nation which is we are not hopefully. Let it be clear that the government is fully accountable to the people and not to Crown of England any more or be it White House today! The Commodore's critique is therefore a self inflicting averment, an insidious distraction from culpability of a serious nature of which author makes no mention. Instead missing the wood for trees through unsure   and motivated judgment interpreting the FAX as brief for the Army Chief as an individual when it is not. But decidedly for overriding need to cleanse the mess at higher ranks a mission at his hand which as far as possible must not see change of horses midstream through a controversy of this nature by design. Commodore's silence on this tantamount to condoning and defending wrong is a reflection of flippant inconsistency in his sermons , incompatible with military straightforwardness. He seems carry the tone of an official spokesman for the 'other' camp whatever this may mean!                 

 

Sainiksangh is not an archaic set up with colonial mindset which the author seems to exhibit richly in his rejoinder ( not his fault we  groom functionaries in our still colonial styled military establishments trying to brush up English NOT grooming leaders as why should white masters should have  to groom brown  leaders anyway  , but this continues to this day vigorously  as we carry the nostalgia of Raj and its admirers  ). Our next paper to the RM is exactly for  nationalizing our training philosophy at foundation level and bring quality in intake else we  remain saddled with vagaries of character carried by sub calibre material in a profession where only honour and awe must prevail; admittedly Hindu bourgeoisie never had a military culture to assimilate such values as history bears out amply ; why history is not taught.  The founding principles of Sainiksangh therefore encompass nation building engagement, defining a citizen role for the veteran where he is remains an extension of the military institution outside the establishment when  he chooses to identify so loyally and not peddle agenda for others. This makes us non stereotype engaging in many fields. This is 50th interface with the establishment on various issues exerting pressure to move policy, admission of education subsidy for war widow's children being one.

We are not used to intrusion in our territory by any with coercive intent and share our views only to evoke thought with positive interaction and not to invite subversion. We also do not need any recognition or accolades which we entertain only from children below 18. At our functions the local DM sits in invitees pavilion while watching village girls and boys being the VIPs.

We hope this settles the avoidable and wasteful engagement of this nature.

chauhan
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
- Original Message -----
From: Ranjit Rai
Cc: Brig YUDHVIR ; parvez ; Vinod SAIGHAL ; Veterans for justice ; militray banglaore ; Bombay Sappers ; 109 ; manmohan ; Amit Bhaduri ; rajendra ; manmohan ; Indian Veterans Group ; editor@rajputindia.com ; editor@tehelka.com ; AVM S L Dutta (Retd) ; Ms Barkha Dutt ; B.B.Desai ; kiran bedi ; ajai singh ; surendra srivastava ; Govinda Menon ; Dr Trivedi ; afroz sahil ; nagdads@yahoo.com ; B P S Chandel ; Baldev Lall ; PRO ; Col B Singh ; Sat ; Brig Kr KN Singh ; Wing Cdr Gautam Guha ; Maj Gen SP Aul ; Maj Gen SP Aul ; Brig HS Chaudhary ; Col B Singh ; bhawani ; P Renjen ; SPS Rawat ; Viajay Oberai ; Maj Gen Rajinder Singh,VSM ; Maj Gen Lakhwinder Singh,YSM ; Lt Gen NS Malik, PVSM ; Col M S Krishnamoorty ; kmehra ; Jeet Khanna ; JEET KHANNA ; Kamal Khanna ; kamal khanna ; Maj Gen JS Kapoor ; Lt Gen V K Kapoor ; Atul Dev ; def Air Mshl (retd) s r deshpande ; Rear Admiral Kuruvilla ? ; Maj Gen Pushpendra Singh ? ; Brig P T Gangadharan ?
Sent: Wednesday, August 03, 2011 12:11 AM
Subject: Re: [HumJanenge] FAX TO RM ON DOB Word Document.doc

This Fax was an unnecessary interference by Saniksangh as this a matter  between the AG and MOD and the Chief and what the Chief accepts in the highest and finest traditions of the fine Indian Army he joined and lived with a date in the ARMY LIST, all his illustrious career.

The Army Chief has to set an example and  ensure the controversy ends with the Governments decision, right or wrong. A fax by a self grown organisation  is in poor taste but its a democracy so they can do so,  but to imply  the next Chief if he comes in in 2012 will not be as good as Gen VK Singh smacks of a personal bias and interest in the case though the Fax  cleverly say they have no personal bias. Typical of India seen by PM's statement in 2G/CWG  issued by PMO not himself. Do generals want to be such.


Are we readers of this group so gullible ?  .........If Gen VK gets a lease of life till 2013 a Dynasty Change will take place in the senior line up of the Indian Army and that in an Armed Force will show that we are in 2G category too, intellectually corrupt. We retired, should keep clear and so in many cases, unless you join journalism when more people at large will judge . We retired are  setting up groups that  are not recognized by the Armed Forces and are capable of embarrassing them, like the return of medals. The President does not care for that as RM should dis regard this fax in the WPL.

I hear Sanik Sangh is doing great work in villages and that is laudable .....Let those in uniform now do their job.....We old timers did ours. We would not have liked outside interference.

Lets be retired soldiers, sailors and airmen of self respect.


Cmde Retd Ranjit B Rai as discussed at the golf course today.

On 2 August 2011 06:26, Sainiksangh <gs@sainiksangh.org> wrote:

            vf[ky Hkkjrh; iwoZ lSfud la?k

        All India Ex Soldier's League

 

 
        In Service of the Nation, Society and Fraternity                                                                  

          web site sainiksangh.org Telefax 011-26891513

    e-mail : gs@sainiksangh.org ; web sainiksangh.org

    Tele:     011-26891513   

   HQ : 6090-B8 Vasant Kunj New Delhi                     Priority – URGENT            

To:

Shri AK  Anthony

H'ble Raksha Mantri

 

FAX 

From: Lt Gen GS Growl, PVSM  (rtd)  President  AIESL

Maj Gen APS Chauhan (rtd) President Sainik sangh Vice President AIESL

 

 

 

 

Fax 23015403

 

Pages: 4

 

Copy to Defence Secretary

 

Date:  Wednesday, July 27, 2011

 

Security: Unclassified

 

Transmitted by   Maj Gen APS Chauhan

  

 

 

 

Firstly: Greetings from our fraternity and integrated Graam Samitees.

Secondly:  This memorandum is a fall out from the regrettable controversy  on  COAS's date of birth attracting a public debate  causing  great concern at  the grass root level. 

Thirdly: You are conscious of the assault on reputation and virtues of the military institution on a continuous basis which must have a telling effect not only on our national prestige but pointedly on those sections of rural which field our fighting elements. Now it is the controversy about the date of birth of the incumbent Chief of the Army Staff Gen VK Singh.

On the face if it and simplistically an error or anomalous entry but irreconcilable and incorrigible being on his record. The ramifications of this are however grave and which cannot be wished away or disposed of as simplistically as may appear. This faux pas introduces extremely undesirable and damaging conflict of interests and a predicament for the establishment as to which date should decide the date of retirement of the General. Any choice will be tantamount to becoming arbitrary and challengeable.

Fourthly: We take this opportunity to share our position on this is a matter of concern for the entire veterans community as tarnishing of military image must hurt it most. There are a few postulates which stand out and give direction to resolving this extraordinary and exceptional case.

A: That the anomaly exists and was allowed to, over the entire period of the General's service speaks poorly of our  efficiency in  house keeping,  responsibility for which rests entirely with the Ministry.

B: That the anomaly has been made public, when this is part of a highly confidential document and taken with its timing ,  raises alarm on vulnerability, the lack of integrity and reliability of  those handling these sensitive documents. It follows that this lapse has remained covered in books even if by neglect but leaked with full knowledge of the repercussions of this thus a deliberate act of felony.  This requires immediate action to fix responsibility and book the culprits.

C: Per say and axiomatically the clerical error thus assumes a diluted status becoming inconsequential when taken in context of the larger implication and gravity of the act of leaking the information. This must become a primary concern at the Ministry as it manifests a threat within, in these troubled times and more ahead, with which there aught to be no delay in dealing.

D: Security ramifications aside, a controversy of this nature involving the head of a military service of the nation should never have come to be debated as a law problem in public making us a laughing stock. Military management is not playing snakes and ladders as much as battles not won in court room's .This points acutely at our insensitivity to nuances beyond the immediate for the impact this can have at national level. Specifically sending wrong message to the soldier that the system that fields his commanders is highly suspect, which we think it is , denting his  pride and trust which can result in breakdown of discipline, which is showing so and for which only the  Ministry is finally accountable to the people.

E: Gen VK Singh took charge at an unenviable moment when our military image was already   getting a battering at hands of sub-calibre generalship which logically led him to pledge publicly to attend to the health of the institution as his top priority. As any duty conscious incumbent would in the troubled circumstances and restore confidence at large. That despite a protracted neglect of the institution no earlier incumbent found it necessary to engage such, was in itself extraordinary and a relief.  Indications are that is being apparently pursued vigorously as evident from the indictment of two previous Chiefs for involvement in land scandals.  Indeed his predecessor had not only brought along a dim reputation from Northern Command of which you are fully seized, raising another public controversy, but understandably did all to cover misdemeanors of other  senior officers under his charge some to our knowledge  later indicted or waiting to be  for similar misconduct. The fact that despite his reputation Gen Deepak Kapoor had  been clearing successive rungs of advancement was itself bewildering and intriguing which we are sure is receiving your fullest attention as there cannot be a greater urgency at the Ministry than to shore up its invulnerability, both the MS Branch and the JS (G)  not always carrying the distinction of upholding the credibility of their own offices. Officers with 5 point reports have made to Army Commanders. The leaking of information thus has an uncanny but definite connection with the previous Chief during whose tenure this leak was presumably detected. This affair therefore smacks of a deep conspiracy which must be exposed with urgency in national interest.

F: The higher interest of the Army and national security must remain the overriding factor to set the case at rest without further speculations and delay. An unsettled state of this nature is bad for military morale, distracting and impeding the COAS to conduct his business and disrupting continuity where this may be vital and critical in implementing measures to clean up the inherited mess which is deep and extensive.  For this his services must be available for the maximum period possible much this may mean against vested interests wanting to extract their pound of flesh from this anomaly. We must instill confidence in the military and set a route for  much needed corrections and reforms in officer grooming without which the military cannot be fitted out to deliver the  consequences of which can be mind boggling; provided ofcourse there is a will and inclination to correct the decay.

G: The clerical anomaly must therefore not fog the exercise of decision making in the best interest of the country. Both military and civil bureaucracy must not disconnect with the psychology of the soldier, understood so well by the colonial masters nearly brought to their knees once, which understands only one language that his Chief cannot be brought under dispute whatever the nature as he must be spotless in every way  to lead them into battle. We have been avoiding this test so far. 

H:  RM's advice to the military not to fonder media is sound but must be addressed to his Ministry too to create conditions to obviate the need for this.

Fifthly: This memorandum is not a brief for any individual or  a lobby for any interests but one against such what is  inimical to the interests of the soldier and the nation.  An alert on setting right the standards of functioning and conduct which has a bearing on lives of men.

 

Signed

 

chauhan




--
Cmde (R)Ranjit B Rai
Vice President Indian Maritime Foundation Tel 24330087 M 9810066172
International Correspondent India Strategic. Broadcaster
C 377/443 Defence Colony New Delhi 110024
www.indiadefenceupdate.com



--
Aridaman Jit Singh
For Team Nishan
http://www.nishanjustice.org/
http://community.webshots.com/user/Nishan_Justice
http://call100.blogspot.com/

"Highest office in a democracy is not that of the President or Prime Minister but Patriotic Citizen"-Team Nishan
-----------------------
NISHAN Campaigning HQs.
Plot No.571(1st Floor), Sector-2,Urban Estate, Kurukshetra-136131(Haryana),India. Tel. - +91 1744 232013,TeleFax- +91 1744 232570,(M) +91 9466283343
--------------------------------
NISHAN Liaison office Haryana: S.C.O.86(Top Floor), Sector-17, Kurukshetra-136118,(M) + 91 9466283343
-------------------------------------
NISHAN Registered Office Delhi: 9-CSC, DDA Market, A-Block, Saraswati Vihar, Delhi-110034,India,(M) + 91 9899007392