Dear Capt. Beniwal, Thanks for the information. I did'nt know that SC judges are also entiutled for pension after one days service. Hari Goyal (Prof. Hari Dev Goyal) indian Economic Service (1968 Batch) --- On Wed, 30/5/12, capt beniwal <trident142@yahoo.co.in> wrote:
|
Saturday, June 2, 2012
Re: [HumJanenge] How can we Prevent the On-going Blunders in India - Is RTI Helpful ?
Thursday, May 31, 2012
Re: [HumJanenge] How can we Prevent the On-going Blunders in India - Is RTI Helpful ?
Please ignore such parasites of the society .Do not invite them on any function unless he proves himself as a real patron of the society.Looking at the lavish celebrations made on marriage, birthday and on many such occasions the country is now a safe haven for a limited few of unearned income[Black -Money] persons.Please shun such gatherings with the contempt it deserves.When you are in distress none of these self seekers have time to be by your side for help.It is time for silent protest by each one against such vulgar life style of few. With kind regards A.K.BHATTACHARYYA F.I.StructE (UK), FIE (India), FIBE, FIRT H-2A, Hauzkhas, New Delhi -16, Ph:011-26854127 --- On Wed, 5/30/12, capt beniwal <trident142@yahoo.co.in> wrote:
|
Re: [rti4empowerment] PRESIDENTIAL ELECTIONS -- DR. LEO REBELLO AS THE NEXT PRESIDENT
DR. JN SHARMA
On Thu, May 31, 2012 at 2:39 AM, Leo Rebello
<drleorebello@rediffmail.com> wrote:
>
[HumJanenge] Mal-functioning of Odisha Information Commission (6)
Mal-functioning of Odisha Information Commission (6)
Odisha Information Commissioners never ensure information to the Complainant despite knowing that the order of the Commission to provide information complied neither by the PIO nor the 1st Appellate Authority. The Information Commissioners are working day and night to protect corrupt officials and on-going corrupt practices in Govt.
Dear friends
Since 2011, it has become useless strategy of Odisha Information Commission to arbitrarily dispose the Complaint cases without hearing and remanding to 1st Appellate Authority to provide information to the Complainant. In so-called order, the Commission also asks the complainant to file Second Appeal before the Commission, if he or she is not satisfied with the order of the First Appellate Authority.
Mr. Tapana Mohapatra, RTI Applicant based in Bhubaneswar had submitted an application to the PIO, Office of Tahasildar, and Bhubaneswar seeking information about land issues in vicinity of Bhubaneswar. It needs to be mentioned here that huge corruption and irregularities in respect of land allotment and purchase and sale of land is going on in Bhubaneswar. Getting no response from Govt. Mr. Mohapatra filed complaint before Odisha Information Commission on 6.1.2011. Mr. Pramod Kumar Mohanty, SIC without hearing the Complaint case ( CC No- 02/2011) arbitrarily remanded to the 1st Appellate Authority, office of Tahasildar, Bhubaneswar on 31.10.2011 to dispose the case within 30 days and asked the Complainant to come with 2nd appeal again to the Commission , if he fails to get information.
Finding no justice from the 1st Appellate Authority as per direction of the Commission, Mr. Mohapatra again approached the Commission intimating Mr. Pramod Kumar Mohanty, State Information Commissioner about non-compliance of his order by the 1st Appellate Authority on 9.12.0211. Though more than 6 months have passed, Mr. Pramod Mohanty has neither heard the case nor ensure d information. Mr. Tapan Mohapatra, complainant is waiting for unknown period to get the information.
This is the true Character of Information Commissioners in Odisha. They use their power and authority to protect corruption of Govt. and corrupt officials at the cost of the interest of Complainant-citizens.
If anybody has any query, Please directly talk to Complainant on his mobile ( 94376-35267).
Regards
Pradip Pradhan
M-99378-43482
Date- 31.5.2012
Re: [HumJanenge] RTI-PIO boards on WR-CR Rly stations in Mumbai
Thanks.Regards Bunch --- On Mon, 28/5/12, Mohammed Afzal <mohdafzal1963@gmail.com> wrote:
|
Wednesday, May 30, 2012
Re: [HumJanenge] How can we Prevent the On-going Blunders in India - Is RTI Helpful ?
Goyal sir, what you said is for every body to follow. But for information to all/you the MPs have made themselves ENTITLED to pension by being ONE DAY in parliament, thats after he/she takes oath, because they have omitted the minimum service period from the rule for pension for MPs. any person who was MP for ANY period shall be paid pension, including those members of constituent assembly. Is it not great job done by the MPs of all parties ?. The MPs should serve a minimum of ten years, similar to a public servant, to become entitled for pension and perks. they have also made SC judge entitled to pension after ONE DAY in the court wef Apr 2004. this was done so that no body challange the MPs getting pension after one day in parliament. you may call such act what ever you like, all MPs are together in it. rgds. beniwal --- On Wed, 30/5/12, Hari Goyal <rtidwarka@yahoo.co.in> wrote:
|
Tuesday, May 29, 2012
Re: [HumJanenge] How can we Prevent the On-going Blunders in India - Is RTI Helpful ?
We the citizens of Real India take certain steps immediately: 1. We must stop addressing the Ministers in Centre and in States, addressing them 'Hon'ble' 2. No body including ministers and their relatives not living with them also should get free security staff when they are paid from the common man's contribution to Central and State Taxes. 3. No free passes for air travels and by railways for the family members of the buraucrats. 4. No pension for any MP or MLA if he/she has not served for 20 years at least. No question of pension after 5 yeras of getting MP ship or MLA ship. There should be record of time and days when the elected so-called representative in Partliament and State Assembly. 5. Travelling by vehicles for the members of Babus for getting vegetables from the market, going to schools and colleges by sons/daughters of Babus must be stopped. Let them hire taxis by paying from Babu's salary. Hari Goyal 30.05.2012 --- On Sun, 6/5/12, Mahesh Khera <mkkhera@yahoo.com> wrote:
|
Monday, May 28, 2012
[HumJanenge] Fw: [IESM_Group:323] Lt Gen SC Sardeshpande's Open Letter
DEAR CITIZENS, KNOW HOW WELL OUR GOVT WANTS TO PROTECT & DEFEND INDIA AFTER SPENDING YOUR & MY TAX MONEY & PONDER. Moron Media might tell you that here is another Gen like Gen VK SINGH, who IS blowing a whistle for his own benefit Thanks for your time. Best Wishes. Tel : 91-22-2412 1656 > 9 am to 9 pm = GMT + 5 1/2 hrs. Mob : 91 - 9820813951 \ 98201 88926 Minoo Mansion, 799 J J Road, Dadar East, Bombay - 400 014, India --- On Mon, 28/5/12, CK Sharma <seekayess@gmail.com> wrote: From: CK Sharma <seekayess@gmail.com> |
[HumJanenge] HC stays CIC order for inquiry against sr officers
Asking Information Commissioner Shailesh Gandhi to repond by November 1, Justice Vipin Sanghi stayed his order setting up an inquiry against Anita Gupta, First Appellate Authority, M C Sharma, retired PIO, S Padmanabha, CPIO and Akash Deep Chakravarti, Deemed PIO and JS(Law) on an application filed by Naveen Kumar Peer under the Right To Information (RTI) Act alleging that the officials have failed to give "satisfactory" reply to his plea.
Justice Sanghi passed the order on the plea of Chakravarti, an IAS officer and presently posted as Deemed PIO and JS(Law) with CIC, through counsel Rajiv Bansal challenging Gandhi's April 19 interim order for the inquiry.
Acting on a RTI plea of Peer alleging that the reply sent by the department was without signature, Gandhi had examined the records and ordered for setting up an inquiry against the CIC officials under section 18 of RTI Act and also summoned them to appear before him.
"A reply from the Legal Cell without any any date and signature or name of person providing the informations states that the appellant (Peer) filed many RTI applications after sending letters which were incoherent....
"The total facts revealed before the commission do not appear to be compatible. The commission is therefore setting up an inquiry under section 18 of RTI Act to uncover the true facts," Gandhi said in the interim order.
As per Chakravarti's petition, "The respondent 1(Gandhi) has in a malafide manner, grossly misused its powers vested in him under the RTI Act and has clearly acted in a manner denying natural justice to petitioner (Chakravarti)...."
He contended that the order was passed without even issuing show-cause notice to him.
Chakravarti claimed that Peer had filed more than 5000 applications under RTI before CIC and said in December 2010 he had written a letter to the commission under the title "all held decisions due to civil writ petitioner number 12210/09 and 13550/2009 against CIC and others with High Court, New Delhi" which was "without clearly describing either the subject matter or the issue concerning him."
According to the petitioner, Peer had also sought an appointment with the concerned CIC officer to offer his suggestions and service which was in the form of letter but not an application. However, the reply was sent to him in February but being aggrieved with the reply, Peer had filed a plea before First Appellate Authority.
Again in April, 2011, another reply was sent to him but Peer filed a second appeal before the information commissioner in May last year.
PTI
http://goo.gl/xTcGl
Re: [HumJanenge] Appointment of CIC in 2010
From: Sarbajit Roy <sroy.mb@gmail.com>
To: humjanenge@googlegroups.com
Sent: Monday, May 28, 2012 8:05 PM
Subject: Re: [HumJanenge] Appointment of CIC in 2010
Dear Karira
You are starting at the wrong point in time.
Mr.ANT was slated to become the first C'IC. Unfortunately (for RTI
regime) Mr. Habibullah used his networking with No.10 (Janpath .. and
possibly Downing Street through MI6) to be appointed instead. In fact
the RTI ACt in 2005 was such an important legislation (at the time)
that ANT could not be relieved from DoPT till the Act was
operationalised.
Mr ANT fought it out later with MMA (???) on a point of principle. =
He was senior on all counts.
Sarbajit
On 5/26/12, C K Jam <rtiwanted@yahoo.com> wrote:
> Dear Mr M K Gupta,
>
> Please
> refer: http://www.rti.india.gov.in/cic_decisions/CIC_SM_A_2011_001098_M_83270.pdf
>
> You were given the entire file by DoPT and during the hearing CIC SM
> surmised for you that no shortlisting was done, when IC ANT was elevated to
> CIC (after CIC WH demitted office).
>
> Here is what you actually wanted to know:
>
> The story actually started when CIC WH "resigned" from office to go to J&K
> as its first Chief SIC. That resignation was left in a limbo and had a
> bearing at the time of resignation of IC Omita Paul. Subsequently, when CIC
> WH did demit office he same "suggested procedure" was adopted.
>
> Here is the full story as to how it was done:
>
> http://www.rtiindia.org/forum/61045-cic-may-go-headless-thursday-no-decision-new-chief.html
>
>
> Between 2010 and 2011, I had obtained all documents related to elevation of
> IC ANT to CIC from the CPIO of CIC and PMO. A summary as to what happened
> behind the scenes, is available in post #2 here:
>
> http://www.rtiindia.org/forum/61753-jk-interlocutors-veteran-scribe-researcher-info-commissioner.html
>
>
> In case you want, I have all the documents with me.
>
> When you analyse those documents, you will learn that how childish can 65
> year olds become - just to get the "Chief" tag attached before their
> designation.
>
> Keep a careful watch on the order of appearance of the photos of various ICs
> in the CIC (on the CIC home page). Do homework with their CVs......and you
> can safely predict the order of future Chief IC till Feb 2017 !
>
> RTIwanted
Re: [HumJanenge] RTI-PIO boards on WR-CR Rly stations in Mumbai
Sent from my iPhone
Friends last year after struggling with Western Railway for almost 13 months I manged to get around 800 PIO boards installed in Western Railway from Churcgate to WR limits.( East and West sides)Few days back I got confirmation from HQ-CR that they have finished installing with Mumbai Divn and the rest are in process throughout CR limits.For information and wide publicityRgdsRaja John Bunch-9969972283National Campaigner for Right to Information.(NCPRI)
Re: [HumJanenge] Appointment of CIC in 2010
You are starting at the wrong point in time.
Mr.ANT was slated to become the first C'IC. Unfortunately (for RTI
regime) Mr. Habibullah used his networking with No.10 (Janpath .. and
possibly Downing Street through MI6) to be appointed instead. In fact
the RTI ACt in 2005 was such an important legislation (at the time)
that ANT could not be relieved from DoPT till the Act was
operationalised.
Mr ANT fought it out later with MMA (???) on a point of principle. =
He was senior on all counts.
Sarbajit
On 5/26/12, C K Jam <rtiwanted@yahoo.com> wrote:
> Dear Mr M K Gupta,
>
> Please
> refer: http://www.rti.india.gov.in/cic_decisions/CIC_SM_A_2011_001098_M_83270.pdf
>
> You were given the entire file by DoPT and during the hearing CIC SM
> surmised for you that no shortlisting was done, when IC ANT was elevated to
> CIC (after CIC WH demitted office).
>
> Here is what you actually wanted to know:
>
> The story actually started when CIC WH "resigned" from office to go to J&K
> as its first Chief SIC. That resignation was left in a limbo and had a
> bearing at the time of resignation of IC Omita Paul. Subsequently, when CIC
> WH did demit office he same "suggested procedure" was adopted.
>
> Here is the full story as to how it was done:
>
> http://www.rtiindia.org/forum/61045-cic-may-go-headless-thursday-no-decision-new-chief.html
>
>
> Between 2010 and 2011, I had obtained all documents related to elevation of
> IC ANT to CIC from the CPIO of CIC and PMO. A summary as to what happened
> behind the scenes, is available in post #2 here:
>
> http://www.rtiindia.org/forum/61753-jk-interlocutors-veteran-scribe-researcher-info-commissioner.html
>
>
> In case you want, I have all the documents with me.
>
> When you analyse those documents, you will learn that how childish can 65
> year olds become - just to get the "Chief" tag attached before their
> designation.
>
> Keep a careful watch on the order of appearance of the photos of various ICs
> in the CIC (on the CIC home page). Do homework with their CVs......and you
> can safely predict the order of future Chief IC till Feb 2017 !
>
> RTIwanted
Re: [HumJanenge] We are Doomed with Selfish and Shameless Political Decision Making - Air India
I dont know how this reflects on the self created crisis in our
national carrier.
We have lots of relatives of our political class parked there on a
permanent basis right from sukh ram, lalooji, tiwariji, pawarji and
not to miss rajat sharmaji's own brother.
So cant touch it. Hope the pilots take pity on us.
Regards.
On 5/19/12, Arun Virmani <avarchitect@gmail.com> wrote:
> Hi All,
>
> Visiting Toronto, in the midst of our longish visit to New York, India can
> be seen in
> a better Perspective.
>
> Air India, should long have been privatised. If we are the only Fully
> operated Government Carrier(and Not justified)
> then sustained Effort should Continue to be mounted on the Government, To
> do so now!
>
> This crisis is an opportunity to do so Now, and Let all of Us hope for it,
> and Do whatever we can!
>
> We Indians have to give up the trait of Not punishing the Wrong Doer...the
> guilty.
>
> We have to work hard ourselves; A mantra i have picked up
> "
> "People Do what you inspect, and Not what you Expect !"
>
> So our work is cut out for us, we have to take it seriously.
>
> Here in Long Island, a very important elecfed leader is called a
> 'Supervisor' and she is running the whole Town !!
>
> Let us Work seriously.
>
> Arun
>
>
>
>
> On Thu, May 17, 2012 at 12:56 AM, Prem Gaba <premgaba@hotmail.com> wrote:
>
>> Dear Friends,
>>
>> There has been a public out cry in the media since long to privatise Air
>> India. This has been a big drain on the nation's resources. The money
>> saved can be better utilised to eliminate poverty.
>>
>> It is high time that this esteemed "Maharaja" is given a farewell & let
>> the corporates run the Airlines.
>>
>> Col Khera's concern & deep anger are justified.
>>
>> Regards
>>
>> Prem Gaba
>> ------------------------------
>> Date: Wed, 16 May 2012 03:45:02 -0700
>> From: mkkhera@yahoo.com
>> Subject: [HumJanenge] We are Doomed with Selfish and Shameless Political
>> Decision Making - Air India
>> To: humjanenge@googlegroups.com
>>
>>
>> Dear Friends,
>>
>> We are the only country in the world which has a national carrier fully
>> owned and operated by the government. Air India has already bled us, the
>> citizens of 100,000 Cr tax payer money and our BPL figure is 32/-. Is any
>> one answerable ? Does any one ask also about why selfish and shameless
>> political decision continues for Air India ? All politicians have sealed
>> their lips.
>>
>> Look at the Army. One case of disobedience of orders and in less than 24
>> hours, decision is taken to sack the commanding officer and disband the
>> unit. Kudos to the Army for living up to its highest standard of
>> discipline.
>>
>> Air India has eaten away 100,000 Cr of citizens money and Parliament has
>> all the time to waste on frivolous discussion on democracy of 60 years. If
>> Minister of Civil Aviation has any self respect, he would have forced the
>> PM to call for an emergency meeting and proposed the sell off of Air
>> India.
>> If PM has any self respect, he would call for a cabinet meeting to prepare
>> a resolution and then discuss it in Parliament, get the approval and have
>> it endorsed by the President. All this in 48 hours. Above all, what is Mme
>> Sonia Gandhi doing as UPA II Chairperson ?
>>
>> Brilliant RTI minds and excellent lawyers in the esteemed HJ group,
>> request save the nation through what ever is possible, RTIs/PILs/court
>> case
>> etc etc. I have no idea. May God save us.
>>
>> Jai Hind.
>>
>> With warm regards,
>>
>> Col Mahesh Khera
>>
>> *
>> *
>>
>
>
>
> --
> Arun Virmani
>
Sunday, May 27, 2012
Re: [HumJanenge] We are Doomed with Selfish and Shameless Political Decision Making - Air India
Dear Friends,We are the only country in the world which has a national carrier fully owned and operated by the government. Air India has already bled us, the citizens of 100,000 Cr tax payer money and our BPL figure is 32/-. Is any one answerable ? Does any one ask also about why selfish and shameless political decision continues for Air India ? All politicians have sealed their lips.Look at the Army. One case of disobedience of orders and in less than 24 hours, decision is taken to sack the commanding officer and disband the unit. Kudos to the Army for living up to its highest standard of discipline.Air India has eaten away 100,000 Cr of citizens money and Parliament has all the time to waste on frivolous discussion on democracy of 60 years. If Minister of Civil Aviation has any self respect, he would have forced the PM to call for an emergency meeting and proposed the sell off of Air India. If PM has any self respect, he would call for a cabinet meeting to prepare a resolution and then discuss it in Parliament, get the approval and have it endorsed by the President. All this in 48 hours. Above all, what is Mme Sonia Gandhi doing as UPA II Chairperson ?Brilliant RTI minds and excellent lawyers in the esteemed HJ group, request save the nation through what ever is possible, RTIs/PILs/court case etc etc. I have no idea. May God save us.Jai Hind.With warm regards,
Col Mahesh Khera
[HumJanenge] RTI-PIO boards on WR-CR Rly stations in Mumbai
Friends last year after struggling with Western Railway for almost 13 months I manged to get around 800 PIO boards installed in Western Railway from Churcgate to WR limits.( East and West sides) Few days back I got confirmation from HQ-CR that they have finished installing with Mumbai Divn and the rest are in process throughout CR limits. For information and wide publicity Rgds Raja John Bunch-9969972283 National Campaigner for Right to Information.(NCPRI) |
Re: [HumJanenge] We are Doomed with Selfish and Shameless Political Decision Making - Air India
Dear All Which other Airline will aitfor Mantriji toarrive.. Shameless people want this JOKE of AIR India to continue Commander PK Jain --- On Sat, 26/5/12, R. Dua <r.dua1234@gmail.com> wrote:
|