Re: [HumJanenge] CIC Habibullah's corrupt decision on Narmada Dam

Dear Sarabjit          The significance of this mail relating to the year 2006 being put on rti board after over  4 years, is not clear.Further, it is also  not clear as to how you became the 3rd Party in a case matter of information relating to the 3 Member Ministerial Committee Report on SSP. Could you please elucidadte   S K NANGIA --- On Sun, 28/11/10, sroy 1947 <sroy1947@gmail.com> wrote: From: sroy 1947 <sroy1947@gmail.com> Subject: [HumJanenge] CIC Habibullah's corrupt decision on Narmada Dam To: humjanenge@googlegroups.com Date: Sunday, 28 November, 2010, 3:53 PM http://humjanenge.org.in/forum/index.php/topic,7.0.html Appeal No CIC/WB/C/2006/00066 Dated: 19/4/'06 Right to Information Act – Section 7(1) Name of Applicant: Shri Shekhar Singh, Smt Aruna Roy & others Name of Public Authority: Prime Minister's Office Corrupt Chief Information Commission gives hearing within 48 hours to email complaint of NCPRI big guns. Aruna Roy and Shekhar Singh had filed a "life or liberty" RTI request to secure copy of a 3 ministers report on SSP. They were already in possession of informal copies, but Medha Patkar's advocate (another NCPRI big cheese) needed an "official copy" to file in Supreme Court immediately. On coming to know about this life or liberty request,  Prakash Kardaley contacts me (being in Delhi) to immediately oppose disclosure of this information to his NCPRI compatriots. I promptly email a "3rd party" request to PMO, which is acknowledged and is transferred along with NCPRI's request to Ministry of Water Resources. Along with NCPRI I also receive a 3rd party notice for the CIC hearing. As per RTI Act the CPIO cannot release information without intimating the 3rd party and giving him opportunity to file appeals. I and Veeresh Malik (another Hum Janenge moderator) reach the CIC venue well in time. We find that neither Aruna Roy nor Shekhar Singh are present, instead they have sent Arvind Kejriwal. The moment the hearing commences, the CPIO of MoWR informs the CIC that as per instructions of his Minister (Saifuddin Soz) he has just handed copies of the controversial report (clearly marked as Confidential /Top-Secret etc) to Ms Aruna Roy outside the hearing chamber so that Prashant Bhushan can file the same in court the next day. I strongly protest at this mockery of RTI Act / abuse of RTI process/ denial of my 3rd party rights etc, but Habibullah and Ansari have been bought off. The completely biased and corrupt order he delivers leaves no doubt that he is a puppet. The order has been deleted from the CIC website by Habibullah. Now here is that order, attached so that the public of India can remember what a corrupt person Mr Habibullah is, and how he used the CIC like a condom for the NCPRI.