Re: [HumJanenge] CIC minutes of meeting

Dear Members

As list owner, I am required to ban this email ID of Mr Mahendra Kumar
Gupta for the reason of continually interrupting and impeding the
discussions on this group.

After examining the record of this thread I find that Mr Sarbjit had
clearly given the link to the CIC's MOM concerning the "rating" of
inverters.

When Sh Habibullah commented adversely on Mr Sarbjit's conclusion that
these were "third rate" inverters, Mr Sarbjit promptly set out the
portion of CIC's MOM which notes that "first rate" inverters are to be
provided and that "basic infrastructure" is lacking in the CIC.

There is thus an on-going debate/discussion between 2 senior RTI
personalities about an important issue of great interest to all RTI
users, viz, the dismal performance of the CIC's Mail/dak system.

Thus for Sh M.K.Gupta to misrepresent that Mr Sabjit is "levelling
unfounded allegations and charges" is clearly not borne out by the
record of this group.

For the moment Mr Gupta's other email ID is retained for posting
responsible and well thought out messages to this list.

PMK

On Fri, Dec 3, 2010 at 5:05 PM, Mahendra Kumar Gupta
<mkgupta1952@gmail.com> wrote:
> I request Mr. Sarbajit to inform the members of concluding that the
> inverters were of 3rd rate.
> After retirement of a respectable official, we should not take his peace by
> levelling unfounded allegatons and charges. I know, Sarab may go to the
> extent to brand me a stooge of former CCIC, which will again be an unfounded
> statement.
>
> On Fri, Dec 3, 2010 at 8:01 AM, wajahat habibullah <whabibullah@gmail.com>
> wrote:
>>
>> Really Sarbajit! 3rd rate inverters?
>> Never mind. Continue jesting
>> Wajahat
>>
>> On Thu, Dec 2, 2010 at 11:48 PM, sroy 1947 <sroy1947@gmail.com> wrote:
>>>
>>> http://cic.gov.in/CIC-Minutes/Minutes23112010.pdf
>>>
>>> I haven't annexed it inline. Some interesting points
>>>
>>> 1) IC(AD) has moved ahead in the pecking order
>>> 2) CIC(WB) bought 3rd rate inverters for dak section
>>> 3) CIC to chase up Draft Rules with DoPT (so that
>>> they can withdraw their SLP in SC and deny me the
>>> pleasure of exposing Mr Habibullah like the last time).
>>>
>>> Sarbajit
>>>
>>>
>>> On 11/27/10, PMK1504 <humjanenge.owner@gmail.com> wrote:
>>> > http://cic.gov.in/CIC-Minutes/Minutes16112010.pdf
>>> >
>>> > Minutes of the Meeting held on 16 11 10
>>> >
>>> > *Present:*
>>> > Sri A N Tiwari, Chief Information Commissioner
>>> > Sri Satyananda Mishra, Information Commissioner
>>> > Smt Annapurna Dixit, Information Commissioner
>>> > Sri M L Sharma, Information Commissioner
>>> > Sri Shailesh Gandhi, Information Commissioner
>>> > Secretary and officers assisted the Commission.
>>> >
>>> > *Agenda 1: Draft RTI rules- for discussions*
>>> > Commission discussed the draft rules and suggested some modifications.
>>> > The
>>> > changes as suggested by the Commission shall be incorporated and sent
>>> > to the
>>> > Government at the earliest.
>>> > (Action: Secretary/JS (law))
>>> >
>>> > *Agenda 2: Status of Helpline for the Commission- for information*
>>> > Secretary apprised the Commission that the helpline would be put in
>>> > place by
>>> > the middle of the next week. He further apprised that appropriate
>>> > procedures
>>> > are being met as of now.
>>> > (Action: JS (A &P))
>>> >
>>> > *Agenda 3: Approval of payment on enhanced rent and service tax for
>>> > AKB- for
>>> > information
>>> > *Noted.
>>> >
>>> > *Agenda 4: Draft cabinet note on declaration of CIC as grants in aid-
>>> > for
>>> > information
>>> > *Noted.
>>> >
>>> > *Agenda 5: A brief analysis on RTI applications received by the Public
>>> > Authorities
>>> > and the appeal/complaints by CIC
>>> > *Commission discussed the analysis and desired that such analyses are
>>> > required
>>> > more frequently.
>>> > (Action: DS (PP))
>>> >
>>> > *Agenda 6: Suggested format for the portal in compliance to the
>>> > direction of
>>> > the
>>> > Commission u/s 19 (8) (a)
>>> > *Commission adopted the format as circulated for uploading the
>>> > personnel
>>> > related details and functions of Public Authorities in terms of section
>>> > II
>>> > of its
>>> > order CIC/AT/D/10/000111 dated 15 11 2010. Commission directed the
>>> > secretariat to take up the matter with the NIC for creating a portal on
>>> > which
>>> > these informations would be uploaded. This exercise would be completed
>>> > at
>>> > the earliest but in no case later than two weeks of time.
>>> > (Action: DS (PP)/Mr Paul, NIC))
>>> >
>>
>
>