Re: [IAC#RG] Fw: Forget Gujarat: Look at the Congress Record: It is Shocking

Dear Wg Cdr Chaddha

Firstly the email seems to have originated from one Mr. Lal Motwani on 4 April at 11:45 AM, but the original email has disappeared off the net So the only work Gen Malhotra did was to fwd it, and for which we are grateful.

Secondly, if I, derive a better explanation, from the data and which fits the facts better, it is known as the "scientific method". Or, do you propose that we all behave like robots clapping in unison for Mr. Modi and shut off our brains ?.

Thirdly the only non-Congress riot (as per you) took place in 2002 under Mr. Modi, so that is another reason not to have him.

Fourthly, are you arguing with my conclusions or with the data itself ?.

Fifthly, in all the cases listed there was a riot which the concerned State Govt failed to control. The problem is that it was the BJP/RSS behind many of these 21 riots. For instance, would you blame the 1992 riots on the Congress or the BJP (or on ISI) ?

ERRATA: In my first email, the figure for 4 out of 21 riots should be around 20% and not 25%

Sarbajit

On Sat, Apr 6, 2013 at 2:46 PM, SK Chadda <chaddask@gmail.com> wrote:

Dear Mr. Sarabjit

 

The facts mentioned by Gen Malhotra are opening. The inference drawn by you is rubbish.

Your arguement ia absolutly baseless. The data given by General clearly mentions that all the

riots have taken place only under Congress government. Why there is such hue and cry over

Gujrat riots.

Till date no commission / enquiry or even the court has blamed Modiji. It was a retaliation by mob

after Godhra incident. Please learn to accept truth and stop misinterpret / misrepresent the facts.

If Modiji's governance has been good in Gujrat, what stops you to accept it. Your knowledge on some issues

may be good but it does not mean that people will fall in line of your imagination. 

Many salutes to General Deepak Malhotra who must have really worked hard to provide such data.

 

Wg Cdr SK Chadda