Re: [HumJanenge] RTI IS NO MAGIC WAND

Any law is as strong as its citizens.

But remember it is not guns that fight. It is hands that hold the gun fight. It is not hands that hold the gun fight. It is the heart of gun holder that fights.

 

-J. P. SHAH 9924106490  
http://www.jps50.blogspot.com/

  

---

From: Anita Vijay Mehta <vmehtaudctbby@hotmail.com>
To: humjanenge@googlegroups.com
Sent: Wednesday, 9 November 2011 9:21 PM
Subject: RE: [HumJanenge] RTI IS NO MAGIC WAND

You have understood these facts sooner than later. All the Acts till date meet the same fate not only RTI....Why??  My view is as follows...
 
We all are to be blamed... The law field was left to all and sundry since 1970/1965, everybody wanted to be Doctor, Engineer,CA etc... Only the left out became Law graduates and Advocates ...  the system is thus clogged with substandard brains .. who has to bid more  time to learn and grasp and the society has to pay in terms of delay and high fees...
The Bench and Bar is such an AKHADA where the litigant is a guineapig who keeps on paying/ suffering in terms of money and time in the hopes of justice.. which he seldom get iff he survived till then....
 
Vijay Mehta.

---

Date: Wed, 9 Nov 2011 06:38:33 -0800
From: lesals2000@yahoo.com
Subject: [HumJanenge] RTI IS NO MAGIC WAND
To: humjanenge@googlegroups.com

Being 5 years in RTI field , i feel RTI is no Magic wand, its a lottery, lucky if u get results, if queries are tough chances are you will not get reply from PIO, or get vague reply who you can call grandson, then u go into 1st appeal complain u/s 19(1) its like going to the PIO's father, rarely will some one scold his son, if one is not satisfied that you go to the Grandfather 2nd appeal your hearing will come after 18 months or more at least in Mumbai thats the way it is, this Grandfather is another Joker, does not peanalise PIO, no monitory cost to applicant, passes order to give the documents if there is merits in case, PIO still does not comply,

even if peanilised seldom does one pay up. then u make complain u/s 18 to SIC/CIC, as complains are not time bound, your complain will only gather dust, NO JUSTICE at all, SIC/CIC APPOINTED BY GOVT. TO PROTECT GOVT BABUS,after they retire SIC/CIC do not even give up their luxirious flats given to them when in office.thats what RTI is all about, however i have come across one Mr J.P.Shah from Gujarat, who has found ways to tackle this menance.i feel besides being a RTI activist he is probally an Advocate

his drafts are perfect, S.R. was also good learned but today i feel he's like swamy agvinesh

Lok Pal bill will be the same as RTI  ABI KAI KARANGA MAI BUDA HO GAYA AUR MERA TABYAT BIGAD GAYA.

Leslie Almeida