Re: [HumJanenge] Fwd: CIC

Me 2. RTI is so unkoool

On 11/14/10, Metrodesk Ptinews <metro.ptinews@gmail.com> wrote:
> Please unsubscribe me. I don't want to receive emails like this.
>
> Rajesh Kochhar
> PTI
>
> On Sun, Nov 14, 2010 at 7:02 PM, bimal khemani
> <bimal.khemani@yahoo.co.in>wrote:
>
>>
>>
>> Friends
>> I am attaching here with 6 documenmts
>> Smt. Premlata Sharma applied to CPIO, BSNL , Aligarh
>> for inspection of a particular file ( 01.jpg )
>> The CPIO did not responded while after First appeal the FAA
>> has sent his reply with a copy of affidavit ( 02.jpg & 03.jpg )
>> Smt. Premalata filed her 2nd appeal before CIC ( 04.jpg )
>> The funny order of CIC ( 05.jpg )
>>
>> BSNL , Aligarh is headed by a General Manager with various brances like
>> Commercial, Accounts, Engineering etc. The applicant wanted inspection of
>> a
>> file which is available with the commercial section, . The FAA who is DGM
>> in
>> adminstrative department, without going into the details sent an affidavit
>> signed by his Commercial officer stating that the file is not available
>> in
>> his branch , the FAA in place of searching file in other departments under
>> his control, choose to take this shortest route.
>> The matter was referred to CIC with a prayer that the authority be
>> directed
>> to give an affidavit recording the reason for the lost of file.
>> The case was fixed for hearing on 12-10-2010, The appealant sent an E.mail
>> as well as FAX to the Asstt. Registrar of CIC on 11-10-2010, which was not
>> put up in the record and in absence of the appellant the appeal was heard.
>> The learned CIC in his decision did not considered the prayer of the
>> appellant and given the decision within the framework of RTI gave his
>> verdict like a High Court judge.
>> I am failed to understand, under RTI how CIC can ask the appelant to
>> approach the public authority for refund of her money with interest.
>>
>>
>>
>> BIMAL KUMAR KHEMANI,
>> TRAP group of RTI activists
>> ALIGARH (U.P.)
>> Mob:09359724625
>> ******************************************
>> Officially Certified A Grade by DoPT
>> *****************************************
>>
>>
>