Sent from BSNL with my BlackBerry® smartphone
The Secretary,
Department of Personnel & Training/GoI
Kind: Attn: Ms Alka Sirohi
Dear Madam
I thank you / your Department for providing me a copy of the SECRET OM to you from the Ministry of Home Affairs (OM 19/15/2011-Judicial-PP) enclosed for your ready reference in the electronic form along with the comparison of MHA on draft Lok Pal Bills.
I am now even further caused to complain as follows:-
a) That the consulatrion process on this Bill is limited to Political parties, politicians and a few handpicked fomrer public servants now masquerading as civil society reresentatives on the Joint Drafting Committee.
b) That there is no opportunity for citizens like me to submit their views on the Lok Pal Bill
c) It is still not clear to me why eminent persons like myself were not appointed to the Joint Drafting Committee
d) How the confidentiality of consultative processes will be maintained when SECRET documents addressed to you by other Ministries are disclosed to private citizens in contravention of the Official Secrets Act so casually by your juniors ?,
With best Wishes
Sarbajit Roy
B-59 Defence Colony
New Delhi 110024
Tel : 09311448069
To:
The Secretary,
Department of Personnel & Training
By EMAIL
Dear Madam
I am reluctantly caused to complain to you concerning the quality and bonafides of private persons nominated for the Joint Drafting Committee for Lok Pal Bill (which is under your purview), specifically Mr Prashanth Bhushan (Advocate).
I am appending an email forwarded to me by one Justice (Retd) Kamleshwar Nath alongwith comments of Mr Prashanth Bhushan asking for wide publication / circulation of a scandalous email (attached) defaming his co Committee member and Union Home Minister Mr P.C.Chidambaram.
As your department's CPIO has still not informed me why Mr Bhushan was appointed to the Joint Drafting Committee instead of myself, I further complain to you that in view of Mr Bhushan's comments I insist (as guaranteed u/a 19) to be provided a formal opportunity of submitting my comments / objections / suggestions via a public consultation process on the draft LokPal Bill as and when it is finalised or placed before Parliament as is the usual practice.
Kindly also place this email and its annexure on the official record of the Joint Drafting Committee or forward it to the Convenor / Secretary thereof to be placed on record.
With best Wishes
Sarbajit Roy
B-59 Defence Colony
New Delhi 110024
Tel : 09311448069---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Justice Kamleshwar Nath <justicekn@gmail.com>
Date: Sat, Jun 11, 2011 at 12:17 PM
Subject: FW: chidambaram
To: Activist Sarbajit Roy <sroy.mb@gmail.com>, "Activist N. S. Venkataraman" <nsvenkatchennai@gmail.com>, Afzal Ansari <patrakarsadan@gmail.com>, Anti-corruption Lucknow 1 <iaclucknow@gmail.com>, Anti-corruption Lucnow 2 <upbeulko@gmail.com>, Anup Kumar Malhotra <anupmalhotra37@yahoo.com>, Anupam Gupta Rourkela <anupam7366@rediffmail.com>, Anupama Jha TII <anupama@transparencyindia.org>, Anurag Gupta <anuragupta7@rediffmail.com>, gupta_av@hotmail.com, Arun Gupta <neerjarun@satyam.net.in>, Arvind Gupta <arvindjgupta@gmail.com>, Ashok Haranahalli <ashokharanahalli@gmail.com>, Anil Bairwal <abairwal@gmail.com>, Avinash Kumar <avinashkr@yahoo.com>, B R Lal TII <br_lall@yahoo.com>, "B. K. Verma TII" <birendra_verma78@yahoo.com>, Balashankar <editor@organiserweekly.com>, Bharat Vikas Parishad <bvp@bvpindia.com>, "Bhavana V. K. Shukla" <vk_shukla@hotmail.com>, Brijendra Parashar HT <bkparasharlko@rediffmail.com>, Chandrika Prasad <chandrika_prasad@yahoo.com>, Chetna Kumar <chetna19@yahoo.co.uk>, "Chief Election Commissioner S. Y. Quraishi" <syquraishi@eci.gov.in>, DC Verma <dcverma06@gmail.com>, Deepali Gupta <deepali.gupta@gmail.com>, Dhananjay Gupta <dhan_jay_g@yahoo.com>, "Dharmadhikary K. R." <krdharma@yahoo.co.in>, Dhiraj K Gupta <dhirajkg@gmail.com>, Dhruv Kumar <groovy.dhruvy@gmail.com>, Dinkar Gupta <dinkarg@gmail.com>, Diwakar Gupta <diwakargupta@gmail.com>, "Dr. Rashmi Gupta" <rashmi1949@hotmail.com>, admiralrht@hotmail.com, ashok@aroraz.com, icdwivedi@gmail.com, karankharb@gmail.com, mgd@airtelmail.in, p_s_bawa@yahoo.co.in, nac.pankaj@gmail.com, ramkhandelwal29@gmail.com, rsrinivasan32@gmail.com, gpf18@gmail.com, Gandhian Satyagraha Brigade <gandhiansb@gmail.com>, ypanandindia@yahoo.co.in, Hardeo Singh GPWO <hardeosingh@rediffmail.com>, Hindustan T Sunita Aron <saron@hindustantimes.com>, "I. B. Singh" <ibsingh@hotmail.com.>, "IAS(retd) Ravindra Gupta" <rgupta@doe.ernet.in>, Jagdish Gandhi <jgandhi@cmseducation.org>, "Judges Assn Justice R. C. Lahoti" <lahotirc@gmail.com>, Ashok kumar Srivastava <justiceaks@yahoo.com.sg>, Justice Devi Pd Singh <dprasadsingh@allahabadhighcourt.in>, Justice I S Mathur <ismathur@satyam.net.in>, Justice Pradeep Kant <pradeepkant@hotmail.com>, Justice S Sodhi <savibonny@yahoo.com>, "Justice S. C. Sharma HOD CAT Alld" <diva.dev9@gmail.com>, Justice Salahuddin Mirza <ashshan@cyber.net.pk>, Lokayukta UP <lokayukta@hotmail.com>, Mahendra Lalka <mahendra_lalka@yahoo.com>, Manisha Agarwal <manisha.law@gmail.com>, Media Rakesh Upadhyay Zee <rakesh.upadhyay@zeenetwork.com>, "Media S. S. Tripathi" <aisna.world@gmail.com>, Media Sandeep <news@dailyaag.com>, Neerja Arun <drneerjaarun@gmail.com>, Murli Manohar Joshi <murli@sansad.nic.in>, Narendra Deo <deonarendra740@gmail.com>, Narendra Kumar Gupta <nkgupta@am.iitd.ernet.in>, Neerja Arun <aayusharun@yahoo.co.in>, NGO Exnora Innovations <chaturvediramakant@yahoo.co.in>, Niranjan Pandey <npandey1@in.ibm.com>, Omkar Razdan TII <niyamshanti@yahoo.com>, ORGANISER Sachin Garg <sachin.garg32@gmail.com>, "P. K. Singh Mankapur" <singhpks123@gmail.com>, "Piyush Gupta (Prem ji)" <piyush_distributors@yahoo.co.in>, Prabhakar Gupta <guptaprabhakar@yahoo.com>, Prakash Singh DG <prakash1959@gmail.com>, R N Srivastava TII <rnath123@hotmail.com>, "R.K. Ohri" <rkohri@airtelmail.in>, Raj Kumar <waykm@rediffmail.com>, RAJEEV AGARWAL <rajeevagarwal.lko@gmail.com>, Ram Autar Agarwal <devesh24@sancharnet.in>, Ram Dutt Tripathi BBC <ramdutt.tripathi@gmail.com>, Ravi Shankar Prasad <ravis@sansad.nic.in>, "S. K. Agarwal TII" <snehsantosh@gmail.com>, "S. N. Shukla" <shukla.sn@gmail.com>, Sandeep Pandey <ashaashram@yahoo.com>, Santosh P Gupta <gupta.santosh@mahindra.co.in>, "Gupta,Sapan" <Sapan.Gupta@standardchartered.com>, Satish Gupta <gupta_sc@hotmail.com>, Sharat Pradhan <sharatpradhan@rediffmail.com>, Speaker LS Meira Kumar <speakerloksabha@sansad.nic.in>, Subramanian Swamy 1 <swamy39@gmail.com>, Sudarshan Padmanabhan <padmanab@gmail.com>, Surendra Prakash Goel USA <goelusa@hotmail.com>, Umashanker Pandey <usplko@yahoo.co.in>, urvashi sharma <rtimahilamanchup@gmail.com>, Vikas Agarwal <vikas_ee@hotmail.com>, yogendra Narain <yognarain@gmail.com>
Cc: Arvind Gupta <arvind_gupta_lko@yahoo.co.in>, "B. K. Verma TII 2" <lprince33@gmail.com>, Chetna Kumar <chetna19@gmail.com>, "IAS(retd) Ravindra Gupta" <ravindra_gupta2005@yahoo.com>, Media Rakesh Upadyaya II <rakesh.varanasi@gmail.com>, "R. K. Ohri Pers" <rkohri@patriotsforum.org>, Ram Autar Agarwal <rag@del2.vsnl.net.in>
Dear All,
Forwarding herewith an eye opener on P. Chidambaram Minister who presided over violence on peaceful fasting Satyagrahis at Ramlila Grounds New Delhi at midnight of 4th/5th June 2011.
Knowledge is strength; let People know.
Regards,
KN
From the Desk of :
Justice Kamleshwar Nath
Retd.
:
Up-Lokayukta ( Karnataka ),
Vice Chairman – C.A.T ( Allahabad ),
Judge – High Court ( Lucknow & Allahabad )
Address
:
`Gunjan', C - 105, Niralanagar, Lucknow : 226 020. Uttar Pradesh, India
Phone(s)
:
+91-522-2789033 & +91-522-4016459. Mobile : +91-9415010746
From: Janhit Manch [mailto:janhitmanch@gmail.com]
Sent: Saturday, June 11, 2011 10:32 AM
To: aastha.atray@gmail.com; Abhay Mokashi; Abhijeet Bhilavadikar; Abid dhule; admiralrht@hotmail.com; Adolf D'Souza; Adv Kotimbere; "Adv. J. P. Dhanda"; advanilk@sansad.nic.in; advocate girija varma; advocate indira unninayar; advocate mayank misra; advocate venkatesh rao; Afsar usmani; Ahmad M.Abdi; ajaitley@sansad.nic.in; Ajay Marathe; Ajit Bhattacharjea; Ajit Ranade; Alka Dhupkar (Correspondent); Anand Castellino; Anand Desai; anant trivedi 1; Anees; aneeshphadnis@gmail.com; Mr.Anil Mehta; Anil Singh; anil_desai@ml.com; anil.ksingh@timesgroup.com; aniljoseph2073@hotmail.com; anjiebose@hotmail.com; anwar bagwan pune; "Aruna CNN-IBN"; "Aruna CNN-IBN2"; Asha Gopal Nair; Asha Patil; ashariff@ncaer.org; Ashish Kothari; Ashish Mehta; Ashish Pendse"" <ashish.pendse@expressindia.com>, "Ashok Chawan" <ashokchavanmind@rediffmail.com>, "Ashok Pandit" <ashok_pandit17@rediffmail.com>, "Ashok R.Jukar" <juksons@yahoo.com>, "Ashutosh Shukla"; Ashwin Karia; Ashwin Shah; asim.human@gmail.com; aspee@aspee.net; ateeq84@gmail.com; Azim Jalna; b_rakesh@dnaindia.net; B.N. Srikrishna; B.S.Vasa; babu.mathew@actionaid.org; Babubhai Desai; bakerandcompany@yahoo.com; bala_wg@yahoo.co.in; bapudeedwania@gmail.com; bb_sharan2003@yahoo.co.in; Bhanuprasad parikh; bharatkadam35@gmail.com; Bhaskar Prabhu; Bhaskar Prabhu; "bhavika jain"; bhedakanti@rediffmail.com; Bhupen Patel; Bhupendra Singh Thakur; bihar - bibek anand 1; bimal.khemani@rediffmail.com; bmahesh@dnaindia.net; bobby.nagi@gmail.com; brlall@gmail.com; brlall@yahoo.co.in; broadband@relianceada.com; bunch_raja@yahoo.co.in; cabinetsy@nic.in; cbmassociates@gmail.com; cgraiyani@yahoo.com; champakdalal@yahoo.com; champanerkar@gmail.com; chandrashekharp@hotmail.com; chauhanyashvantsinh@yahoo.co.in; cheryl d'souza; Chetan S.Batavia; chetankothari53@yahoo.com; chiefminister@maharashtra.gov.in; Chitrangada; chitrangada.choudhury@hindustantimes.com; choufer@rediffmail.com; chpatelck@gmail.com; CHRI; citispace; Clara Lewis; Colin Gonsalves; colrama@hotmail.com; Common Cause; Communist Party Of India; contact@janhitmanch.org; coregroup@ppi.net.in; cse@cseindia.org; cvcmumbai@gmail.com; D. R. Poddar; Mr.Damji V.Savla; Dankesh Oza; debigoenka@gmail.com; Deborah Grey; deepa_tkadam@yahoo.com; Deepak Doshi; deepakmehta@gmail.com; Delhi Forum; "desai geeta"; Dhananjay Sompura; dhananjay tingal; Dhanya Indian Express; Dhiren Bhuta; dhruvraja@hotmail.com; Dr.Dilip Galal; Dilip J Mehendale; Dinesh D.Shah; Dinesh S.Shah; Dinesh Thite; dipalimshah@gmail.com; Dipti Deshmukh; divan@vsnl.com; Divyakant Mehta; "DNA"; "DNA speakup"; Dolphy D'Souza; dostitrust@yahoo.co.in; drjaypandya@hotmail.com; dte@cseindia.org; editorial@mm.co.in; editors@indiatogether.org; elan.consultants@gmail.com; dr Eshaan ambernath; etvnews@hathway.com; fahim bhiwandi; faiyaz pune; Dr.Fatema I.Jetpurwala; fightingterror@hindustantimes.com; Flavia Agnes; Forum for Fast Justice; Forum for Free Enterprise; frcf_b22@hotmail.com; G P shaikh Ahmed nrg; G. M. Jain; G.R.Vora; gandhim@sansad.nic.in; gandhipeacefoundation18@yahoo.co.in; GandhiServe Foundation; gaurjk@hotmail.com; Mr.Gautam; Gene Campaign; Gerson; Gerson Dacunha; Ghar Bachao Ghar Banao Andolan; Dr.Girish Sanghavi; Gopal R.Hegde; Gopalkrishnan iyer; Gordon D'Souza; gpf18@rediffmail.com; gr8sammy4u@gmail.com; guna raj; GURUNATH AV; gvtdwarka@yahoo.com; H.S.D'LIMA; Hansel Dsouza; hansrajb@sansad.nic.in; Harakhchand V.Gala; hari agrawal; Haria Exports Ltd.-Kavita; Harsukh Mehta; Hasmukh M.Shah; Mr.Hasmukh Parsana; Hema Sampat RTI; Hemang Tannaa; "hemant morparia"; Her Excellency President of India Smt. Pratibha Devisingh Patil; himanshu joshi; "Hindustan Times"; "Hindustan Times"; Hiren Shantilal Batavia; Hiten Anandpara; Hon'ble Prime Miister of India Dr. Man Mohan Singh; Hon'ble Chief Justice of India Mr K G Balakrishanan; hrvakhariy; "HT Sayli Udas Mankikar"; Hussain Akola; hvgandhi84@gmail.com; Ibrahim Akola; IC Dwivedi; ideamumbai@yahoo.com; "India Today"; "Indian Express"; Indra Sawhney; indraneel@dspdesign.co.in; Indur Chhugani; info@cmsindia.org; info@mkgandhi.org; J.M.Mehta; Jagdeep DESAI; Jagdeep S.Chhokar; jaiex2001@yahoo.com; Jain Jayant; jainravikiran@yahoo.co.in; Jairaj Phatak Commr MCGM; James John; Janak D.Dwarkadas; Janhit Manch; janhitmanch@vsnl.net; jaswant@sansad.nic.in; jaygraphics_pln@yahoo.co.in; jitenmody2005@hotmail.com; jitu11in@yahoo.com; joshi.krishna@indiatimes.com; jp@loksattaparty.com; Judicial Reforms .; Jugal S. Rathi; jui_gangan@yahoo.com; justicekn@gmail.com; kailashrr@rediffmail.com; Kajal Iyer; Kamal Jaswal; kamsri2005@yahoo.com; Kanubhai suchak; kanubhai@hotmail.com; kanunayak@gmail.com; karmayog@yahoogroups.com; Kaushik Suchak; kbthakker2007@yahoo.co.in; kcsekhar@ias.nic.in; kdsarkari@yahoo.com; kedar diwan; kerpl@vsnl.net; ketaki@kgoswami.com; Ketan H.Mehta; Khinvasarachavan; kidsedutainment@hotmail.com; Kirit J. Shah; kishoreshahdadpuri@yahoo.com; Kotimbere sholapur; Dr.Kranti Kumar Sharma
Subject: Fwd: chidambaram
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Prashant Bhushan <prashantbhush@gmail.com>
Date: Thu, Jun 9, 2011 at 11:28 PM
Subject: Fwd: chidambaram
To:
Dears All,read this outstanding article by Arun Agarwal on why chidambaram fears the Lokpal and put it on as many websites and magazines as you can. Disseminate it as widely as you can.
Warmly,
Prashant
---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: arun agrawal <angrywal@hotmail.com>
Date: Thu, Jun 9, 2011 at 1:41 AM
Subject: chidambaram
To: Prashant Bhushan <prashantbhush@gmail.com>, Shanti Bhushan <shantibhush@gmail.com>, arvind kejariwal <parivartanindia@gmail.com>, Parivartan <parivartan_india@rediffmail.com>
Please go through the attached file on Chidambaram.
BR
Arun
--
use ubuntu.com instead of microsoft windows and remain FREE from viruses and trojans
www.openoffice.org
http://www.janhitmanch.org/judicialdelayssolutions.pdf Reforms for the Indian justice system
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.