Re: [IAC#RG] Insult to the nation

Dear Jitender

I have taken the trouble to locate the said Parliament debate from
1998 for you. Luckily the official record agrees with my recollection
of it even if it is is watered down .
http://www.indiankanoon.org/doc/1294074/

"SHRI RAJESH PILOT (DAUSA) : Let me please say one sentence.
[Translation]
Hon. Minister of Home Affairs, Shri Advani may please excuse me, but
why we are concerned ? You were here on 3rd of December. ! was the
then commu­nication Minister and I had told something. I had told that
I am coming from Lucknow and the mosque will be demolished. Shri Atal
Bihari Vajpayee and you both were sitting here and none uttered a
word...(Interruptions)So, I would tike to ask from you that being the
Minister of Home Affairs, could you promise that till the decision of
the court, you will not let the temple to be con­structed
(Interruptions) "

About 'Saare Jahan se Achcha Hindostan hamara', I think you are
confusing it with a later work by the poet Iqbal. If not, why cannot
you openly say what are the words/text in it you have objections to ?

Sarbajit

On 5/15/13, Jitender Khurana <yesjitender@yahoo.com> wrote:
> Dear Sarbajit ji,
>
> 1. Thanks for enlightening us on Burq.
>
> 2. As you said -
> Mr. Rajesh Pilot stating that day that on 3-Dec-1992 he had informed the
> Lok Sabha that the Mosque would be demolished and UP Govt should take
> action - but that Atal and Advani sat with their ears, eyes and mouths
> shut (Pilot was killed in suspicious circumstances shortly thereafter).
>
> Rajesh Pilot died after 8 years in Year 2000...So??
>
> 3. You also said-
> Unfortunately the song which should have been India's national anthem
> could not be considered because its author had become an idealogue for
> Pakistan. I am referring to "Saare Jahan Se Achcha Hindostan Hamara" which
> stands far above both these songs and which goes to show that the
> creation is more important that the Creator.
> Believe me if this would have been National Anthem then we would have got
> big arguments refering to various religious books, causing too much
> tension. Its lyrics are far more controversial.
>
> Jitender khurana
>
>
>