I agree about the independent authority. In my view, it should come under the women and children welfare ministry. If homeschooled children can be registered as homeschoolers and for a fee, perhaps community monitoring or individual visits by observers would help ensure that homeschooling doesn't provide a smokescreen for child labour or abuse - for example, though it is too new in India for such misuse at this point (there are other excuses used that are more known and common, in other words). Or some other solution. However, such a solution must not impose a syllabus or tests - that defeats many of the reasons people homeschool. Life learning is not easy to quantify and test the way you can with a text book with specific questions and answers. Besides, homeschoolers learn very differently from school - the range of subjects is more diverse and there is no subject that is "compulsorily covered". Also homeschooled children tend to gravitate toward very advanced learning on the subjects they are interested in - as you see from the young ages of those who went for the IIT-JEE exams. There is no way to devise a standard test that could measure homeschooling performance with any reliability. Perhaps a more qualititative assessment - for example submissions of examples of whatever learning is going on - videos, photos of creations, copies of written work, etc. This will need a lot more debate than one person's view on the matter.
Emotional and social development is not a worry at all with homeschooling, in my view, though some parents have expressed concerns about their children not having homeschooled company to play with (many homeschoolers don't like the aggression of schooled children). However, to the best of my knowledge, I have yet to see a homeschooled child who cannot socialize excellently with the world. If you stop to think for a minute, when you take isolated sitting in class out of the picture, even that time is spent immersed in real world contact for homeschoolers. They learn in the real world, and as such, most homeschoolers are genuinely puzzled by why anyone would imagine they cannot function in the world they inhabit exclusively. As the parent of a homeschooling 16 year old put it once, "I don't know why people think socializing doesn't happen. All we do is socialize! Even when we are learning something else!"
Here is a description of a Homeschooling Conference I attended with my disabled son. I think it captures the social wisdom of homeschooled children very well.
Vidyut
Vidyut
On Thu, Jun 25, 2015 at 3:36 PM, Vidyut <wide.aware@gmail.com> wrote:
With due regard, JK Gaur, Tomar, Indira Gandhi or Smriti Irani are not homeschoolers. I fail to see how you can demonize a learning choice over the actions of those who never made it. They reflect the enslavement of school conditioning where self-worth is measured in numbers and papers and a lack feels threatening enough to fake having them.Why not measure the worth of homeschooling with the actions of homeschoolers instead of products of the school system? Ignorance? While we tend to value everything the children do, here are some that ought to impress the worst slave of the education system as well.Rabindranath Tagore was homeschooled. Sahal Kaushik, who topped IIT-JEE at the age of 14 in 2010 is homeschooled. Satyam Kumar, homeschooled son of a farmer cracked it at 12. Angad Daryani, who created India's first 3D printer is homeschooled. Shreya Sahai who fought and lost a case to get recognition for homeschooling at the age of 15 is homeschooled. Julian Assange, who founded Wikileaks is homeschooled. Thomas Edison, Alexander Graham Bell, Lewis Caroll, Robert Frost, Franklin Roosevelt, Theodore Roosevelt, Florence Nightingale and many many more inventors, artists, philosophers, reformers and more were homeschooled. Here is a list of homeschooled scientists. The site also contains other famous homeschooled people. Many Indian arts have survived because of homeschooling traditions from Sangeet gharanas and dance forms to elaborate silk weaves and musical instrument making. I have yet to meet a homeschooled child over 10 who wasn't doing anything interesting - that adults would find interesting and useful. This is far more than I can say about schooled graduates who spend 15 years chasing paper and still have no idea what they want to do. An average homeschoolers coference has everything from filmmakers to skateboarders and inventors to urban farmers. Probably not good enough for your standards.So you will pretend homeschooling is to blame for products of schooling with inferiority complexes over paper degress like Tomar or Irani or Tawde or Indira Gandhi or whoever. Because all you know outside the respect for schooling system is lack of respect for the garbage from the schooling system. Your examples have nothing to do with homeschooling. Yet you use them to deny rights of children who wish to do something worthwhile with their childhoods instead of your pet form of assembly line child raising.There is considerable evidence that homeschooling is far better than school for emotional development at the very least.Here are some more sources (different from previous email) if you are interested in being informed instead of simply demonizing something because you have decided it is bad.Here are some of my views copy pasted from another place about the harms of school. As an unschooling parent who has not just been to school, but was a star student all through, and then led a diverse life including corporate training where much of the work is undoing the damage from school, these are my dead honest thoughts. They may be a bit extreme for those who believe in school, but at least they aren't blaming schoolers for acts of homeschoolers or vice versa:Schools
- You might want to remember when any genius ever said, oh, I'm a genius because school taught me all the important things. That's right, never. Its usually, mom, supportive family, special mentor, country, god, etc.A school is a facility to install softwares of a list of subjects on unformatted children and certify the output, so that they may be put to appropriate use on becoming adults. In other words, kids are glorified hard drives.
- Schools kill learning. Destroy ability to learn. Learning is a process of differentiation.This is red, this is blue. It is the discovery of the difference that I learn. A math problem can be figured out usefully by doing this and not this. Clearly, the process of being wrong is as important as the process of being right. If you cannot be wrong, you have validated nothing. You have only recorded what was told.
- If you don't memorize railway timetables or helpline numbers, there is absolutely no reason to memorize biological species or latitude and longitude coordinates of a city.Schools are a criminal waste of the most learningful years of a child's life.
- Think of the brain as a computer's RAM. It caches information, but it is information it needs handy for instant application. Cluttering the cache limits its utility. We get children to memorize tomes and tomes of history, scientific classifications, geographical information, mathematical methods, and what not. Like any good cache, it flushes after the exams, or at worst, after education is complete. A school creates a fake need for storing information.
- What about English? A child can learn to read and write entirely from its interests.Video game rules, titles of cartoon films, story books, etc give way to chatting with girlfriends, reading up experiments…. whatever. When they have an interest that needs reading, they figure it out. If they don't need it, there is no need, is there? If you write like Wren and Martin, you need to search for jobs in nineteenth century England. This is the language of the world. You find it on blogs, newspapers, instruction manuals, application forms and appointment letters.
- Language is about communication. And knowledge is about function. My excellent English grew through reading story books. I was absolutely addicted to story books. I used to hide them inside text books and read them in class. Lost count of how many got confiscated. I dare say I made a significant contribution to the school's library. I used to read story books while waiting for exams to start. If I didn't waste time on school, my English would have been even better.
- What about Maths? Prof Lockhart does a fantastic job of demolishing the myth of maths as taught in schools, and Joyce finishes the job for anyone who thinks a genius has different standards and they are more ordinary. Do read both. BTW, a calculator is cheaper than school fees. Here's one by Ben Goldacre on the scientific ethics of schools and adults –Kids who spot bullshit, and the adults who get upset about it
- Now for the uncomfortable parts. School does kids harm. It has done you harm. It has done society harm. It has done me harm. The reason is that schools measure the worth of people. They respect or insult based on measures they decide and do damage, because they teach that human beings are less worthy if they don't know something. They fail to comprehend or instill respect for the vast scope of genius existing in the world. They install inferiority complexes, superiority complexes, and an inability to recognize genuine knowledge growing wild. It diminishes people.
- Schools create artificial perceptions of narrow, age defined social comfort zones.People who hear this for the first time think I'm being unreasonable. They think kids preferother children their own age. If this were true, pre-school kids wouldn't be tagging behind elder siblings in hero worship. It is an instinct to look at experienced members and learn. It is unnatural to avoid diversity. Pay attention – I am not saying relationships of same age are unnatural, I am saying it is unnatural not to venture outside those ages. Our society is fragmenting, as generations are unable to relate easily with each other. The few families with healthy relationships make it. The rest is a saga of all the generations finding the other generations inconvenient at best and intolerable more often.
- Schools create a culture of isolation. That would seem surprising considering how there are so many children, and you remember having friends…. but you can socialize and be alone without the ability to form meaningful relationships. Schools police interpersonal relations to an astonishingly harmful degree. It is natural for two people with a common problem to join forces in solving it. In real life, we call it team working. In school, the challenges are called examinations, and collaboration is called cheating. There is shame, stigma and a strong emphasis on NOT giving or accepting assistance and solving problems on your own. Then, you go to work, and suddenly the school ideas are the ones creating most of your trouble. You can't ask for help, you can't accept help, because you are "worth less" if you do that.You agree to teamwork, but still communicate final versions. Silo culture. There are now increasing cases of depression, suicides and loneliness in school children.
- Schools are a market. A big, profitable market, where the consumers have no rights.
- The education system is INEFFICIENT. In a world where efficiency and speed are important, the size of education only increases, becomes more and more schizophrenic and irrelevant to reality. Increasingly, the products of this education system are worthless in real life. <== READ! They find it difficult to see opportunity in a city like Mumbai (<== READ!), where my illiterate maid earns Rs.12,000/- a month. Basically, our education system is still geared to produce clerks in the British Raj.
- Schools teach very few of the life important skills, and little that is useful for non-white collar jobs. A train driver earns a good income, but kids are not exposed to it as an opportunity. They are herded toward academic brilliance as though it were an Olympic sport and functionality were not important.
- I don't even want to talk about all the class stereotypes this creates. Intelligent, respectworthy people score well in exams.This has been disproved so many times, its irrational. But what do you expect in a country where people become teachers because they couldn't get better jobs?
- The education doesn't create a foundation going beyond the known or fighting the horizon and breaking through. The idea is to do what is already established, excellently. A child is innovative by nature. A doer, experimenter, natural scientist. It is a creative lobotomy to force them to become like this.
I am sorry if this post appears excessively ranting, but with our children's rights at stake, it really is not funny when ignorant people demonize us for the actions of the school system.VidyutVidyutOn Wed, Jun 24, 2015 at 1:36 PM, Gaur J K <gaurjk@hotmail.com> wrote:24/6/15Academic excellence should not be the sole criterion for determining a good school. Physical,social and emotional development is equally important for a child int he age group of 6 to 14. How will home schooling take care of these aspects.Secondly there has to be an independent authority to judge the competence of the HomeSchool children at some stage.Some NGOs have considered taking the PIL route for quality education but have decided against it.Tomar is not the first to make a false claim. Indira Gandhi was in Oxford but did not complete the degree but claimed to be an alumnus.There are some other names as well, the latest being Smriti Irani. Education confers social repectability and employability. That is why it is a flourishing racket.Education is also becoming a racket- some industrial houses have jumped into it in the garb of CSRand grabing large parcels of land in the name of quality education from primary to postgraduage level.Regds JKGaur
Date: Tue, 23 Jun 2015 10:46:35 +0530
From: gvgrao33@gmail.com
To: indiaresists@lists.riseup.net
Subject: Re: [IAC#RG] Need help securing the rights of homeschoolers
The quintessence of the views expressed by my learned friends is that we should send children to school that also to a recongnised school and not depend on home schooling but it is doubtful whether good schools are available within reasonable distance otherwise any transport made available by school authorities.
On Jun 15, 2015 8:36 AM, "R. Dua" <r.dua1234@gmail.com> wrote:Point understood Vidyut ji.
We all want good ppl to be at the helm of affairs.And childhood is the right time to guide them.
Regards.On 14 Jun 2015 20:38, "Vidyut" <wide.aware@gmail.com> wrote:Also, I don't get the reference to Jeetendra Tomar. To the best of my knowledge, Tomar is a product of a system that values those itty bitty degrees, which is why he had to steal what he didn't have. This is not the act of a homeschooler that you are using to dismiss homeschooling.VidyutOn Sun, Jun 14, 2015 at 3:24 PM, R. Dua <r.dua1234@gmail.com> wrote:One appreciates the social workers good intention.
But as we are seeing Delhi's ex law minister..wats his name, jitender tomar of aap, trying his best to build an a escape route thru various univ's in n out widout any success.
A regular education has no parallel at any level or grade.
Else we will be having high sounding empty vessels all over the place.
We are thankful to authorities for bringing this forward.
Regards to all.On 8 Jun 2015 07:55, "Sarbajit Roy" <sroy.mb@gmail.com> wrote:PIL as proposed will not flyA legal solution to your problem is to take the religious route for MINORITIES .Art 30(1) and obtain a certificate saying you are an Esperanto speaker / Anusthanic Brahmo Samajists etc. enabling you to run your own schoolBTW: It seems the RTE Act acknowledges homeschoolingOn Sun, Jun 7, 2015 at 12:12 AM, Vidyut <wide.aware@gmail.com> wrote:The RTE does not allow homeschooling. The education system we have is frankly pathetic and does little to nothing to provide a useful foundation for life. We are still into memorizing and testing recall in an age of pen drives. Spending hours calculating square roots when every mobile has a calculator and we have more mobiles than toilets. On the other hand, things we'd imagine are life essentials - how is your electricity bill calculated and how to pay it or even what your rights are as a child and what can you do if your rights are violated is something you never learn in school.TEN years of basic education does not make students competent for basic jobs and they must cater to the education inflation craze to be able to make a living. Ten years is a lot of time. We don't see a two hour film without checking reviews to see if it is worth it, yet think nothing of occupying ten of the most eventful years of a child's life with school.What is it that the schooling system teaches and that we need in life that takes ten years to learn?Alternative schools and homeschooling parents attempt to make education more relevant and useful to children. Study after study has shown homeschooling in particular in far more favorable light than schooling systems.India has a small but growing community of homeschoolers who are constantly waiting for the other shoe to drop as the noose tightens around their necks.Most of us are determined that we'd rather face jail ourselves than send our beloved children into one. Yet we are left with little choice than to keep our heads down and continue our "illegal" activity (recently removing a child from school was also termed 'criminal'!) and hope that we never end up facing the law over it.It also hinders the children's rights in many ways. Many events or competitions accept student entries through their schools and homeschoolers not having a school name to put in the form can become ineligible to participate. Scholarships that could dramatically enhance a child's scope (homeschooling isn't cheap) cannot be applied for without the name of the school where the child is learning.Worse, there are places where officials from the education system keep visiting families to insist that the children be sent to school. Alarming reports of government notices to parents not sending children to school.Would it be possible to file a PIL stating that while the RTE is an excellent MINIMUM to offer children, it is hardly the ideal education a child can receive and parents or organizations attempting to raise the bar should not be prevented and forced to accept the mediocre?Advice would be much useful, as we are a small and scattered community with little experience with rights struggles and we have vulnerable children we want to do right to. So there is some fear of being in the government/judiciary's notice with our child's name on record as violating the RTE.VidyutVidyut
Post: "indiaresists@lists.riseup.net"
Exit: "indiaresists-unsubscribe@lists.riseup.net"
Quit: "https://lists.riseup.net/www/signoff/indiaresists"
Help: https://help.riseup.net/en/list-user
WWW : http://indiaagainstcorruption.net.in
Post: "indiaresists@lists.riseup.net"
Exit: "indiaresists-unsubscribe@lists.riseup.net"
Quit: "https://lists.riseup.net/www/signoff/indiaresists"
Help: https://help.riseup.net/en/list-user
WWW : http://indiaagainstcorruption.net.in
Post: "indiaresists@lists.riseup.net"
Exit: "indiaresists-unsubscribe@lists.riseup.net"
Quit: "https://lists.riseup.net/www/signoff/indiaresists"
Help: https://help.riseup.net/en/list-user
WWW : http://indiaagainstcorruption.net.in
Post: "indiaresists@lists.riseup.net"
Exit: "indiaresists-unsubscribe@lists.riseup.net"
Quit: "https://lists.riseup.net/www/signoff/indiaresists"
Help: https://help.riseup.net/en/list-user
WWW : http://indiaagainstcorruption.net.in
Post: "indiaresists@lists.riseup.net"
Exit: "indiaresists-unsubscribe@lists.riseup.net"
Quit: "https://lists.riseup.net/www/signoff/indiaresists"
Help: https://help.riseup.net/en/list-user
WWW : http://indiaagainstcorruption.net.in
Post: "indiaresists@lists.riseup.net" Exit: "indiaresists-unsubscribe@lists.riseup.net" Quit: "https://lists.riseup.net/www/signoff/indiaresists" Help: https://help.riseup.net/en/list-user WWW : http://indiaagainstcorruption.net.in
Post: "indiaresists@lists.riseup.net"
Exit: "indiaresists-unsubscribe@lists.riseup.net"
Quit: "https://lists.riseup.net/www/signoff/indiaresists"
Help: https://help.riseup.net/en/list-user
WWW : http://indiaagainstcorruption.net.in
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.