RE: [HumJanenge] Re: RTI challenges

I have read the various critical comments on Mr. Sarbjit by a number of
esteemed members of this platform. Notwithstanding the same, I would
certainly acknowledge Mr. Sarbjit's quality of arguments. In my view, Mr.
Sarabjeet has put forth the clinching and substantial arguments here.

Ashok Chaitanya

-----Original Message-----
From: humjanenge@googlegroups.com [mailto:humjanenge@googlegroups.com] On
Behalf Of sroy1947
Sent: Saturday, December 11, 2010 5:24 PM
To: HumJanenge RTI India Right to Information Act 2005
Subject: [HumJanenge] Re: RTI challenges

Dear Guptaji

When you say that there are many paths to reach the goal, it proves
that
you are a Hindu. I am not saying this but the Supreme Cout uses this
as a test for who is a Hindu and who is not. This is 1 test of 3 tests
in the "Tilak test of Hinduism" formulated by Bal Gangadhar Tilak.

Hinduism is an inclusive religion, others like Islam, Christianity,
Parsi etc
are not - you must be their adherent to the exclusion of all other
religions. ie. a Christan cannot be a Muslim or vice-versa or a Parsi.

Another test laid down by the Supreme Court is if the convert been
accepted into the community. So if say Sonia Gandhi claims to be a
Hindu, has the Hindu community accepted her as such ? Today if
you go into any village with Hindus, you will be asked for your jaat
and paat and gotra. It is normal in Indian tradition. Many people base
their decisions on such factors. What is the gotra of Sonia Gandhi ?
I say she has none ! As Subsrmanian Swamy has written, even her
name is not Sonia.

Sarbajit

On Dec 11, 4:26 pm, "M.K. Gupta" <mkgupta...@yahoo.co.in> wrote:
> Though I was born in the family of a Vaish (Gupta) in the Hindu religion
yet I
> regard myself as Indian first. I also respect Muslim, Sikh, Christian,
Budha,
> Jainism, Persian and all other religions not mentioned here. The goal of
all the
> religions is one though the ways to reach that goal are different. I
shall have
> been equally happy if I have been born in some other religion as I believe
in
> one religion i.e. 'Humanity' and in servicing of not only human beings but
also
> other creatures of God. We don't have any control to take birth in a
particular
> religion and this is decided by God but we can control ourselves by living
in
> harmonious ways with the followers of all other religions.
>
>
> After the hate messages of Mr. R. Singh have been stopped on yahoogroup,
on this
> group, one member is suggesting to revoke the suspension of another sender
of
> hate messages i.e. Mr S D Sharma to invite such messages. Shame on us. Pl.
do
> not test patience of the members.
>